A simple staple like pepperoni pizza has never tasted so good! I'd eat it for breakfast, lunch and dinner if I could afford eating out that much. Pros: Headline says it all... best... More

A simple staple like pepperoni pizza has never tasted so good! I'd eat it for breakfast, lunch and dinner if I could afford eating out that much. Pros: Headline says it all... best pizza! Cons: There aren't more locations :)
Less

I have eaten at this establishment many times over the last few years and I can honestly say it is the best?.If you love pizza you need to experience Pizza Suprema. They have a great selection of... More

I have eaten at this establishment many times over the last few years and I can honestly say it is the best?.If you love pizza you need to experience Pizza Suprema. They have a great selection of pizza?my personal favorite is the upside down slice?..If you are looking for a true New York slice look no further-the pizza is truly devine:) Pros: excellent pizza, great taste, fast/friendly service
Less

I stopped in and read the owners recommendations: Regular Up Side Down (Like a sicilian slice) Fresh Mozzarella with Basil I had both a regular slice and the Up Side down slice for lunch. Home... More

I stopped in and read the owners recommendations: Regular Up Side Down (Like a sicilian slice) Fresh Mozzarella with Basil I had both a regular slice and the Up Side down slice for lunch. Home run baby! I spoke with the guy behind the counter, he was more excited about the pizza than me. The crust was nice and thin, sauce and cheese were of a good quality and the turnover always has fresh pies out of the oven. Its nice this place is so close to Penn Station. I heard about this place on the internet and I'm passing my review along to others. Its GREAT! NYBULLY Pros: Close to Penn Station
Less

Centrally located, lots of choice, good crust! I would recommend this place not only to pizza lovers, but to those who appreciate good cuisine! Pros: great choice and quality Cons: ... More

Centrally located, lots of choice, good crust! I would recommend this place not only to pizza lovers, but to those who appreciate good cuisine! Pros: great choice and quality Cons: sometimes very busy
Less

When I am meeting someone in the Penn Station/MSG area, I always make Pizza Suprema the meeting spot. Having been born and raised in the NYC area, I am quite familiar with good pizza and not so... More

When I am meeting someone in the Penn Station/MSG area, I always make Pizza Suprema the meeting spot. Having been born and raised in the NYC area, I am quite familiar with good pizza and not so good pizza. From the first time I ate here, I was blown away by the unbelievably delicious food they serve. Before coming here, I always classified pizza as good or not so good, and never really understood why some people would be so adamant about pizza reviews. After eating at Pizza Suprema, I came to understand what really great Pizza was, and finally realized that reviews are not hype. The pizza they serve is always consistent; consistently great tasting that is! My favorites are the regular round, upside down, fresh mozzarella, and white slice garnished with lightly breaded eggplant cutlets. It is not difficult to explain what makes their pizza great, but it would take me too many words to describe. Taste it once, and you will understand. But be advised, you may become addicted, and have difficulty eating pizza anywhere else! PS: the management and staff are always very professional, courteous and gracious, which makes the expereince perfect in all respects.
Less

This place has one of the most unique assortment of pizzas that I've ever tried. My fiance and I love going here every once in a while for a guilty pizza indulgence. Toppings (on slices) Sausage,... More

This place has one of the most unique assortment of pizzas that I've ever tried. My fiance and I love going here every once in a while for a guilty pizza indulgence. Toppings (on slices) Sausage, Pepperoni, Mushroom, Green Peppers, Onions, Anchovies, ground beef , olives. . Another favorite is the Roman Pie Layered with Sausage, Pepperoni, Ham & Cheese. Take a friend or two and enjoy! Pros: pizzas
Less

I come to pizza suprema 3 times a week and its the best pizza ever!! The pizza here is out of this world. From the sauce to the cheese. The thin crust is unbelievable and the fresh mozzarella basil... More

I come to pizza suprema 3 times a week and its the best pizza ever!! The pizza here is out of this world. From the sauce to the cheese. The thin crust is unbelievable and the fresh mozzarella basil is amazing!! I would definitely recommend this pizzeria to anyone who is in the area to try this place out. The owner and workers are very nice! they are the best as well as their Pizza!! All the best! Thank you for making my lunch time enjoyable! :) Pros: EVERYTHING! Cons: NOTHING!
Less

Pizza is my favorite food. It is also the favorite food of my 6 year old son. Our favorite place for our favorite food is NY Pizza Suprema. The sauce is always fresh tasting and flavorful. The crust... More

Pizza is my favorite food. It is also the favorite food of my 6 year old son. Our favorite place for our favorite food is NY Pizza Suprema. The sauce is always fresh tasting and flavorful. The crust is perfect, not spongy or chewy. I like best the regular cheese slice and the basil mozzarella slice. The basil gives it that extra zest. My son's favorite is the upside-down slice on the sicilian crust. The grated cheese on top of the upside down pizza gives it an edge over the regular sicilian slice which is also great! NY Pizza Suprema is one of the few top ranked pizzerias which sells pizza by the slice. This allows you to get your favorite slice-warm hot or even extra crispy. You can even stack two warm cheese slices on top of each other like John Travolta in Saturday Night Fever and eat your pizza while strutting down Eighth Avenue. Finally don't forget to take advantage of the 8pm special which is buy one get one free for shelf specialty slices (not regular slices). Pros: the pizza Cons: i have to travel an hour and a half to get there
Less

SUPERB!!! SUPERB!!! SUPERB!!! SUPERB!!! SUPERB!!! SUPERB!!! SUPERB!!! SUPERB!!! SUPERB!!! SUPERB!!! SUPERB!!! SUPERB!!! Pros: SUPERB! Cons: SUPERB!

SUPERB!!! SUPERB!!! SUPERB!!! SUPERB!!! SUPERB!!! SUPERB!!! SUPERB!!! SUPERB!!! SUPERB!!! SUPERB!!! SUPERB!!! SUPERB!!! Pros: SUPERB! Cons: SUPERB!
Less

I tried to put a new posting in December 2008 but it deleted my original recommendation from earlier this year. When I was working in the area, I loved going to Pizza Suprema for lunch or an early... More

I tried to put a new posting in December 2008 but it deleted my original recommendation from earlier this year. When I was working in the area, I loved going to Pizza Suprema for lunch or an early dinner at least once a week. The place has a "Cheers" kind of feel. The owners and counter guys get to know you. Now that I'm downtown in SoHo, I miss the delicious pizza on 8th Avenue between 30th and 31st Streets. Twice in the last week I've been in the area to go to the post office but it was either too early or too late to get a slice. Hopefully next time my timing will be better. Merry Christmas and Happy New Year to the staff of Pizza Suprema. Pros: Excellent pizza, friendly staff, convenient to Penn Station and Madison Square Garden Cons: It's not near where I'm working now
Less