Pizza is average to good, but the service was soooo bad, that I won't even think of ordering from them again. They brought the pizza to the wrong address, and then when they finally realized that... More

Pizza is average to good, but the service was soooo bad, that I won't even think of ordering from them again. They brought the pizza to the wrong address, and then when they finally realized that (after I had to call THEM 3x - they never called me to try to deliver it) and we got the order, it was WRONG. They botched the order. Called and complained while the delivery guy was still there, insisting that I shouldnt have to pay (or at least not full price) given such service, to which they responded with nastiness and sarcasm. With so many average/decent pizza places around, why would I EVER use this place again?? (I also happen to know that the actual store is dingy, dirty, run-down-looking - not exactly a place that looks food-poisoning-free). Go elsewhere.
Less

I am going to go out on a limb here and say that this unassuming joint in the West 70s is the best regular pizza place in manhattan. It is not comparable to some of the classic New York Pizza... More

I am going to go out on a limb here and say that this unassuming joint in the West 70s is the best regular pizza place in manhattan. It is not comparable to some of the classic New York Pizza places, but for a quick and cheap 2 dollar slice with plenty of cheese and grease, it is number one. While you can get a bowl of pasta or lasagna, stick to the basics. The plain pie, especially when it is straight out of the oven and not overcooked, is the cheesiest and the dough they use is top quality for this kind of a place. They are also friendly people and a good number of comedians come into the place as they have started to publicize through photographs on their wall; There is a well known stand up comedy club around the corner. Go in and watch the cars fly up broadway or order one in, either way, you'll be pleasantly surprised.
Less