Commack Guide
Change Location
My Book
Write a Review
Sign in
or
Join Judy's Book
to contribute
Our Popular Locations:
Atlanta
Baltimore
Boston
Chicago
Cincinnati
Dallas
Houston
Las Vegas
Long Island
Los Angeles
Miami
Minneapolis
New Orleans
New York City
Philadelphia
San Diego
San Francisco
Seattle
Washington, DC
Westminster
See all locations
Browse the top 10 for this Location
Home
>
New York
>
Commack
>
Restaurants
>
Pizza Restaurants
> Emilio's Restrnt & Pizza
Business Details
Top 10 in Commack
»
Restaurants
Your vote has been saved successfully. Thank you.
You cannot vote twice for a Review within 3 minutes.
Emilio's Restrnt & Pizza
Category:
Pizza Restaurants
(
more
)
Category:
Food & Dining
,
Restaurants
,
Pizza Restaurants
(
less
)
2201 Jericho Tpke
Commack, New York 11725
(631) 462-6267
Is this your business?
Get Maps & Directions »
Rate this business
Add to my Favorites
Add to my Rejects
Write a Review
Subscribe to updates
Share
|
Reviews
Trends
Editorials
Rating: 4.1
More
Less
5 star:
33%
(1)
4 star:
0%
(0)
3 star:
66%
(2)
2 star:
0%
(0)
1 star:
0%
(0)
Totals:
Reviews:
3
Rating:
4.1
Share your thoughts with other customers
Totals:
Activities:
3
Share your thoughts with other customers
Share your thoughts with other customers
Owner Message
Maps & Directions
Look Around
THE DETAILS ON EMILIO'S RESTRNT & PIZZA - COMMACK
Categories:
Pizza Restaurants
MORE INFO ON EMILIO'S RESTRNT & PIZZA - COMMACK
Get Maps & Directions
What's Nearby - Look Around
View other
Pizza Restaurants
in
Commack
First member to review:
Read Dominik K.'s Book
Check out
deals in and around Commack
This week's
Top 10 in Commack
People who viewed this also viewed:
Mario's Pizzeria
Amici Restaurant
Olio Ristorante
Street View
Driving Directions
From
To
This business listing hasn't yet been claimed by the owner.
Is this your business?
Reviews
(3)
Trends
(3)
Editorials
(0)
1-Glance Local Reputation
Judy's Book:
CitySearch:
N/A
Other:
N/A
The most helpful favorable review
Emilio's.....best around in the USA!! Forget Chicago deep dish!!
I grew up in Commack & had gone to Emilio's since it was Carmella's. Those of you in Commack know how long ago that was. I moved to Chicago about...
by Roberta P.
More
I grew up in Commack & had gone to Emilio's since it was Carmella's. Those of you in Commack know how long ago that was. I moved to Chicago about 1 1/2 years ago. The people I work with kept telling me that Chicago had the best pizza and everytime I tasted another pizza I almost threw up. I kept telling them "You don't know good pizza." I finally came home this past week & stopped at Emilio's & brought back pizza to Chicago. The following day I took it to work & heated it at lunch time for them. My manager looked at me after one bite & said "This is incredible pizza." I said "I know, New Yorker's know good pizza, Chicagoen's don't. You don't make the crust like a bisquick crust & you don't put corn meal IN the crust." Even Gino's deep dish in the city is disgusting! Chicagoen's need to fly to NY to eat at Emilio's for some real pizza. They will never find it in Chicago.
by Roberta P.
Less
See more
5 star
, 4 star reviews
The most helpful critical review
0 of 1 people found the following review helpful
Bad Knock Off
Emilio’s is your standard Long Island knock off version of New York city pizza. It’s nothing special and I would even go so far as to call it...
by Dominik K.
More
Emilio’s is your standard Long Island knock off version of New York city pizza. It’s nothing special and I would even go so far as to call it substandard. Parking there is also a pain in the you know what. All in all, if you have the choice, go to the Mario’s in East Northport or Commack
by Dominik K.
Less
See more
3 star
, 2 star, 1 star reviews
Emilio's.....best around in the USA!! Forget Chicago deep dish!!
by
Roberta P.
I grew up in Commack & had gone to Emilio's since it was Carmella's. Those of you in Commack know how long ago that was. I moved to Chicago about 1 1/2 years ago. The people I work with kept...
More
Was this review useful?
0
0
Report a problem
I grew up in Commack & had gone to Emilio's since it was Carmella's. Those of you in Commack know how long ago that was. I moved to Chicago about 1 1/2 years ago. The people I work with kept telling me that Chicago had the best pizza and everytime I tasted another pizza I almost threw up. I kept telling them "You don't know good pizza." I finally came home this past week & stopped at Emilio's & brought back pizza to Chicago. The following day I took it to work & heated it at lunch time for them. My manager looked at me after one bite & said "This is incredible pizza." I said "I know, New Yorker's know good pizza, Chicagoen's don't. You don't make the crust like a bisquick crust & you don't put corn meal IN the crust." Even Gino's deep dish in the city is disgusting! Chicagoen's need to fly to NY to eat at Emilio's for some real pizza. They will never find it in Chicago.
by
Roberta P.
Report a problem
Less
Good Pizza
by
Lauren C.
Always busy and extremely loud. The food is great but a little pricey. Vide variety of food. Everything from pastas to seafood. Fabuouls grandpa and grandma slices. Nice place to have lunch with...
More
Was this review useful?
0
0
Report a problem
Always busy and extremely loud. The food is great but a little pricey. Vide variety of food. Everything from pastas to seafood. Fabuouls grandpa and grandma slices. Nice place to have lunch with friends. The parking is not the best but the food is wroth the hassle.
by
Lauren C.
Report a problem
Less
Bad Knock Off
by
Dominik K.
Emilio’s is your standard Long Island knock off version of New York city pizza. It’s nothing special and I would even go so far as to call it substandard. Parking there is also a pain in the you...
More
Was this review useful?
0
-1
Report a problem
Emilio’s is your standard Long Island knock off version of New York city pizza. It’s nothing special and I would even go so far as to call it substandard. Parking there is also a pain in the you know what. All in all, if you have the choice, go to the Mario’s in East Northport or Commack
by
Dominik K.
Report a problem
Less
prev
1
next
Business Activities
Emilio's.....best around in the USA!! Forget Chicago deep dish!!
5 stars
"I grew up in Commack & had gone to Emilio's since it was Carmella's. Those of you in Commack know how long ago that was..."
See Review
on 9/22/2006
Good Pizza
3 stars
"Always busy and extremely loud. The food is great but a little pricey. Vide variety of food. Everything from pastas to ..."
See Review
on 10/18/2005
Bad Knock Off
3 stars
"Emilio’s is your standard Long Island knock off version of New York city pizza. It’s nothing special and I would even go..."
See Review
on 8/17/2005
prev
1
next
Editorials
There are no activities to display.
Back to Top
Emilio's Restrnt & Pizza
Commack, NY
Related Businesses
More
Less
Mario's Pizzeria
3 Reviews
Commack, New York
Amici Restaurant
0 Review
Commack, New York
Olio Ristorante
2 Reviews
Commack, New York
1