Really great pizza with quality ingrediants.Just the right amount of grease running down your wrist. There are few places that get it right on sauce, cheese and the crust, but these guys get it on... More

Really great pizza with quality ingrediants.Just the right amount of grease running down your wrist. There are few places that get it right on sauce, cheese and the crust, but these guys get it on all three. Glad I live in Castle Rock. The only place that could come close is Lil' Riccis, which is now my second favorite after 18 years at the top Pros: Just a great pizza Cons: NONE
Less

Stumpy's is a typical pizza place, with no fancy concept or design. The inside has very minimal seating and a bunch of highschool kids as employees (which isn't bad, but don't expect 5 star dining... More

Stumpy's is a typical pizza place, with no fancy concept or design. The inside has very minimal seating and a bunch of highschool kids as employees (which isn't bad, but don't expect 5 star dining here), so it's best to just grab a pie and go. The pizza is just okay in my opinion (I like Anthony's better!) but their garlic knots are phenomenal! My husband and I love them. We can eat a whole order of garlic knots between ourselves, which is awful because they're dripping in butter and garlic but they are just so darn GOOD! The cinnamon knots are great, too. As long as they keep those two items on the menu, we'll put up with the pizza! Pros: Garlic knots, garlic knots, and oh yes- the garlic knots! Cons: Pizza is just okay, service is spotty
Less

Clearly the best pizza in Colorado. I come from North Jersey where Pizza competitions are frequent and the pizza is arguably the best in the world. For my first 5-10 years here in Colorado, I was... More

Clearly the best pizza in Colorado. I come from North Jersey where Pizza competitions are frequent and the pizza is arguably the best in the world. For my first 5-10 years here in Colorado, I was disappointed every time I ordered a pizza... either too much sauce, too doughy, crappy ingredients, or unedible crust. But when STUMPY's came to my rescue, I found delicious Pizza that would seriously rival my favorites from New York and New Jersey. I am pretty sure Stumpy's uses Semolina instead of flour on the bottom of the pies (I LOVE that). The ratio of cheese to toppings and sauce is perfect, and the meatball toppings are actually chopped up MEATBALLS! And they're Friggin Delicious! I order a Stumpy's Meatball and Onion pie when I have a Meat Craving. That's how substantial the meat and sausage toppings are. The veggies are fresh cut too. You gotta try Stumpy's ! --- South Street Chris Pros: The most delicious Pizza in Colorado, bar none.
Less

Great NY style pizza. Their italian sausage is wonderful, nice and spicy. The location leaves something to be desired, but the pizza more than makes up for that.

Great NY style pizza. Their italian sausage is wonderful, nice and spicy. The location leaves something to be desired, but the pizza more than makes up for that.
Less

Very authenic NY Pizza. I wish we didn't have to travel to Castle Rock to get it. Hope they open a location in the Denver area. Great work guys, keep it up. Pros: They make everything fresh... More

Very authenic NY Pizza. I wish we didn't have to travel to Castle Rock to get it. Hope they open a location in the Denver area. Great work guys, keep it up. Pros: They make everything fresh each day and you can taste the difference. Cons: Located 20 miles south of Denver in Castle Rock.
Less

We get take-out pizza from here often. It is really good and a great price. The toppings taste really good, they use a good amount of sauce and enough cheese that you don't have to order extra. I... More

We get take-out pizza from here often. It is really good and a great price. The toppings taste really good, they use a good amount of sauce and enough cheese that you don't have to order extra. I haven't tried anything else off the menu so I don't know how it would be but I would expect good. The store is fairly busy so I don't know how nice it would be to eat there, I never have but the staff is very friendly. PROS: Good pizza, good price CONS: Don't forget your coupon or they won't honor it
Less

These people make everything from scratch and use stone ovens rather than conveyors. Its so refreshing to not get assembly line pizza. You can taste the difference. Its like going back to NY. ... More

These people make everything from scratch and use stone ovens rather than conveyors. Its so refreshing to not get assembly line pizza. You can taste the difference. Its like going back to NY. This is really great pizza. Pros: Real Pizza
Less