Sign in or  Join Judy's Book to contribute
Share |

Reviews: Locke-Ober

  1. Reviews
  2. Trends
25 Reviews
5 star
(9)
4 star
(9)
3 star
(1)
2 star
(3)
1 star
(3)
Average Review:
25 reviews

Write a Review

Search within reviews:
Search within reviews
The most helpful favorable review The most helpful critical review
Menuism.com
“Scotch. Makes me wish I were a man circa-1950s.”
MoMoney
Scotch. Makes me wish I were a man circa-1950s.

VS
CitySearch.com
“It may be mediocre but at least its pompous.”
RobertDavis10023 10 months ago

Some of the classic menu items are pretty good but you cant get past the wretched location, pompous staff and drole pricing. There are much better... More >

Editorial Review

Eric Grossman, December 15, 2006

A storied tradition of classic American dining is reinvigorated for a new century.
The Scene
When diners see the gleamingly restored turn-of-the-last-century dining room abuzz with foodies, celebs, politicos and high rollers, they understand the Brahmins' loyalty to this American dining landmark. They'll also be reminded of legends of feasts past (Orson Welles slurping oysters by the dozens; Caruso sautéing his own sweetbreads). Co-owner and chef Lydia Shire has been a tonic to Locke-Ober, in the dining room and kitchen.

The Food
Shire packs explosive taste into dishes as simple as Cape scallops and bacon on skewers and beef Stroganoff with hand-cut egg noodles. The kitchen can be slow, but execution is perfect. The crisped duck with elderberry and ginger, for example, arrives unctuously luscious on top, seared to a crunch on the bottom. Indian pudding is a lesson on how this relic of Colonial cooking should be made.

write review

Reviews

< Previous 1 2 3 Next >
citysearch c.
“It may be mediocre but at least its pompous.”
  RobertDavis10023 10 months ago
Some of the classic menu items are pretty good but you cant get past the wretched location, pompous staff and drole pricing. There are much better experiences in Boston. Pros: Older... More >
Was this review helpful to you? ( 0) | ( 0) | Permalink
citysearch c.
“gross”
  Citysearch User
This place is very dirty and old looking. I will never go back here. The food is also mediocre for heavy tab you will be paying. There are other places in the city that offer better quality food. More >
Was this review helpful to you? ( 0) | ( 0) | Permalink
citysearch c.
“Very Very disappointing”
  Susan556
My husband and I were very disappointed with the food and the atmosphere at Locke Obers. We decided to go for a special dinner on a Friday night as it was our anniversary. It was nothing like... More >
Was this review helpful to you? ( 0) | ( 0) | Permalink
Menuism.com
“Scotch. Makes me wish I were a man circa-1950s.”
  MoMoney
Scotch. Makes me wish I were a man circa-1950s. More >
Was this review helpful to you? (0) | ( 0)
Menuism.com
“Fairly decent foie gras with an excellent...”
  LewisZL
Fairly decent foie gras with an excellent pepper steak. I might add that this place is so traditional, it's almost amusing in a humorous way. More >
Was this review helpful to you? (0) | ( 0)
Menuism.com
“I forget what my appetizer was, but I had...”
  marceloc
I forget what my appetizer was, but I had calves liver with prunes and crispy onions followed by hasty pudding. Very traditional but delicious none... More >
Was this review helpful to you? (0) | ( 0)
citysearch c.
“BEST PLACE TO TAKE YOUr LOVED ONE!!!!”
  MattBray
Yesterday my wife and I went to Locke Ober. It was magical. We walked in and were immediatly taken care of. The beautiful coat girl took our coats, the Maitre D' escorted us inside the main... More >
Was this review helpful to you? ( 0) | ( 0) | Permalink
citysearch c.
“Go once to expereince old Boston”
  mrrocki
You can't get more "old Boston" than this downtown dowager located off an alley near Downtown Crossing. The glass and woodwork is magnificent, the real essence of turn-of-the-century Boston. ... More >
Was this review helpful to you? ( 0) | ( 0) | Permalink
citysearch c.
“Classic upscale dining”
  aajay
Correction to the review below. My computer screen was partially covered when I originally filled it out and I meant to give "highly recommended" to most attributes. Sorry. My memory of my one... More >
Was this review helpful to you? ( 0) | ( 0) | Permalink
citysearch c.
“A grand old warhorse”
  secondofficer
It is always amusing, instructive and even pleasing to read a negative review of a place one loves. THose of us who are Locke-Ober devoteees don't mind calumny hurled at the old girl but we of... More >
Was this review helpful to you? ( 0) | ( 0) | Permalink
< Previous 1 2 3 Next >
business image

Locke-Ober

3.8 based on 25 reviews

3 Winter Pl
Boston, Massachusetts 02108
(617) 542-1340

People Prefer These Businesses

  1. 40%
    Preferred
    business image
    40% prefer:
    Metropolis Cafe
  2. 29%
    Preferred
    business image
    29% prefer:
    J P Licks At Newbury Street
  3. 22%
    Preferred
    business image
    22% prefer:
    Hamersley's Bistro
  4. 5%
    Preferred
    business image
    5% prefer:
    Flour Bakery & Cafe
  5. 3%
    Preferred
    business image
    3% prefer:
    Kingfish Hall
Explore similar businesses.