JavaScript is not enabled.
Bethel Bakery Reviews - Bethel Park, PA 15102 | Page 1
10 Reviews
5 star
(3)
4 star
(3)
3 star
(0)
2 star
(1)
1 star
(3)
Average Review:
Search within reviews:
Search within reviews
The most helpful favorable review The most helpful critical review
CitySearch.com
yummmm
by RL70 at Citysearch
Provided by Citysearch
bethel bakery is a wonderful bakery! delicious cakes and creative decorations are only a couple of reasons i go there! the coffeecake is to die for!... More >

VS
CitySearch.com
Embarrassed by the Cake!
by rachel l at Citysearch
Provided by Citysearch
I used to love Bethel Bakery until I ordered my son's first birthday cake from them(July 2010). I drove 45 mins. in the car to order the cake and to... More >

Editorial Review

by Contributor at Citysearch, August 18, 2003

""The Cake Place"": a South Hills tradition for anything from birthdays to weddings.
The Scene
""Baking special memories since 1955,"" Bethel Bakery has etched their names into Pittsburghers' minds as a place to make pastry wishes come true. Simple items like doughnuts,...

write review

Reviews
TrustScore® High

< Previous 1 Next >
citysearch c.
yummmm
  by RL70 at Citysearch
Provided by Citysearch
bethel bakery is a wonderful bakery! delicious cakes and creative decorations are only a couple of reasons i go there! the coffeecake is to die for! and the chocolate cookies are fantastic! More >
Was this review helpful to you? ( 0) | ( 0) | Permalink | Reply | Report abuse
citysearch c.
Very Happy with Service!
  by mhunwick at Citysearch
Provided by Citysearch
We were referred to Bethel Bakery by the Sheraton Station Square. What a blessing! From 300 miles away and over the phone, Anita and Jackie took care of my order. They were friendly and helpful.... More >
Was this review helpful to you? ( 0) | ( 0) | Permalink | Reply | Report abuse
citysearch c.
Embarrassed by the Cake!
  by rachel l at Citysearch
Provided by Citysearch
I used to love Bethel Bakery until I ordered my son's first birthday cake from them(July 2010). I drove 45 mins. in the car to order the cake and to take a picture that I had for thedecorator to... More >
Was this review helpful to you? ( 0) | ( 0) | Permalink | Reply | Report abuse
citysearch c.
good cakes
  by Rlh at Citysearch
Provided by Citysearch
bethel bakery is a good bakery period. their cakes are delicious and the family who owns it are down to earth good people.\r want a good cake? do yourself a favor and come here, you will be... More >
Was this review helpful to you? ( 0) | ( 0) | Permalink | Reply | Report abuse
citysearch c.
Condescending/Overpriced
  by bbsucks at Citysearch
Provided by Citysearch
For some bizarre reason, Bethel people have gotten swept into Bethel Bakery mania. Go out and sample other cakes at wonderful local bakeries. You'll find them way more adaptable to your requests... More >
Was this review helpful to you? ( 0) | ( 0) | Permalink | Reply | Report abuse
citysearch c.
Very rude service, bad pastries
  by DrTrommashere at Citysearch
Provided by Citysearch
I was looking for a place to have my Wedding Cake made at, and of course, Bethel Bakery came very highly recommended. I went and sampled a few cookies, cupcakes, and even had a regular cake made,... More >
Was this review helpful to you? ( 0) | ( 0) | Permalink | Reply | Report abuse
citysearch c.
The name is well known but taste is awful
  by mdcor at Citysearch
Provided by Citysearch
I live in the South hills and Bethel bakery is very well known but the cake has very little taste and is always very dry! My kids would not even eat the choc. chips the frozen cookies in the... More >
Was this review helpful to you? ( 0) | ( 0) | Permalink | Reply | Report abuse
citysearch c.
The Place for a Heavenly Cake
  by minadrac at Citysearch
Provided by Citysearch
This place makes the best cakes, I travel 45 minutes, to get these cakes. They are beautiful and are always fresh and the taste is excellent. I recomend the Choc. fudge icing and Chocolate... More >
Was this review helpful to you? ( 0) | ( 0) | Permalink | Reply | Report abuse
Holly S.
08/2005
155
112
During steeler season they made the coolest shortbread cookie. It was done like a terrible towel. It looked almost to good to eat. They may be a little tricky to find but is worth the trip. ... More >
Was this review helpful to you? ( 0) | ( 0) | Permalink | Reply | Report abuse | Follow Holly S.
Alicia P.
09/2005
0
30
We ordered our wedding cake from Bethel Bakery and were so pleased with it. It looked and tasted exactly how I hoped it would and can't wait to eat the top teir for our 1st anniversary next year! I... More >
Was this review helpful to you? ( 0) | ( 0) | Permalink | Reply | Report abuse | Follow Alicia P.
< Previous 1 Next >
business image

Bethel Bakery

3.25.00.0 based on 10 reviews
Baking Special Memories Since 1955
TrustScore® High

5200 Brightwood Rd
Bethel Park, Pennsylvania 15102
(412) 835-6658

Owners: Incorrect info? Update and Lock your listing here

Best Deals and Recommendations