I love Video to go. I try to go every Monday when they have 2 for 1 rentals; or if I can't make it they always have coupons on their Web site and in the mail. They have a HUGE selection and really obscure titles as well. I love the documentary and special interest sections. They have tons of classics and the staff are very knowledgeable and friendly.
Pros: Huge selection, friendly staff, low prices, lots of coupons
Cons: New rentals slightly pricey, $5 minimum for CC purchases