Trattoria Trecolori

Claim
marker

254 W 47th St (at Between Broadway and 8th Avenue)
New York, NY 10036

marker
(212) 997-4540
Incorrect info? Correct your listing
Reviews
( 33 )
( 6 )
( 2 )
( 0 )
( 2 )

Best

Romantic - as well as great food. Wonderful, casual, perfect before a play, but make reservations. Everything is fabulous! Give it a try, you will not be sorry, and the wine se...

Worst

Arrived at 6 PM for reservation. Were told (by manager? owner?) we'd sit "in a minute". After 10 minutes (we had 8 PM theatre tickets) we asked again how long, and were told ...

pre theatre madness! 10/13/2004

was seated promptly but too close to door and too many people standing by my table. waitstaff was more into pushing the sparkling water than give me a wine menu. had to wait awhile to place order. waiter was friendly but too busy to check back with us. salmon was ok but not fresh and it smelled a bit. the tiramisu was very nice to end the meal with. the Mozzarella en Carrozza was also a nice appetizer. perhaps the place is better after the theatre crowd is gone but we were in the midst of it and it wasn't a very enjoyable experience. Pros: nice menu selection, tempting desserts, average prices Cons: , crowded, not attentiveness more
Reply | Report abuse |

My new Favorite! 10/6/2004

Each time we go here, we are sat quickly. The food is excellent every time! As a garlic fan, I love that they are not shy w/ the garlic in the Penne Arrrabiata!!! The tiramasu is just as good as everyone describes and the house wine selection is pretty good. Pros: delicious food, attentive service, reasonable prices more
Reply | Report abuse |

Thank You!!! 10/1/2004

I needed to organize a rather large dinner party for work and came across this wonderful restaurant thru Citysearch. With the exceptional help of management, from my first phone call to the day of the dinner, I was made to feel that my "party" was their priority. The food was awesome, the room upstairs was perfect and everyone who attended was most pleased. I am looking forward to our next visit to NYC and Trattoria Trecolori!! Pros: Good Service, Great Food more
Reply | Report abuse |

Fantasico! 8/11/2004

Great service, delicious food and nice atmosphere. I had black linguini with seafood and afterwards Tiramisu. Can recommend both and would say its among the best Italian food Ive ever had! Also, reasonably priced for such great food near Times Square, paid about $80 for two main dishes, a shared desert and wine. Pros: Delicious food, Reasonable prices, Great service more
Reply | Report abuse |

Great place to eat! 7/31/2004

I had a wonderful dining experience here. The food was great, the waiters attentive, and the wine delicious! I highly recommend it for a quiet dinner for two. The homemade Tiramisu was out of this world! Great pick! Pros: Immediate service, Great food more
Reply | Report abuse |

Nice Find in the Theater District 7/27/2004

I stopped in here for a pre-theater dinner, and I must say I was very happy with my meal. I was greated within seconds and led to a table. They brought a nice basket of bread, and there was balsamic vinegar and oil at the table for bread and anything else that might need it. The veal was good, and I had a spinach and cheese soup which was also good. For dessert, the ricotta cheesecake is wonderful, and it provides a very nice finish to the meal. The atmosphere, at least on the first floor, is nothing special. If you want a really romantic date spot, this may not be the best place, but the food is good, and it is a great place to get a meal before a night at the theater. Pros: Good food, Good service more
Reply | Report abuse |

Meat tortellini is not to miss. 6/11/2004

Each of the entrees we had was delicious, I especially liked the tortellini (i prefered the meat to the cheese) and the veal was superb. The desserts and cappacinos were great and I look forward to returning to the resturant again. Pros: tortellini, flan more
Reply | Report abuse |

Only one thing lacking, rest is A+ 5/9/2004

Salads are wonderful, esp. the endive! The squid entre was to die for!!! Service could not have been better! The only thing lacking is that you have to shout because of the high noise level but I didn't mind! Pros: Food, Service, Extensive Menu more
Reply | Report abuse |

arrogant waiter! 4/7/2004

Took 16 business clients to dinner based on Citysearch rating. Waiters poured wine like water, my guests were wondering out loud if they would get straws for the wine next. Tipped him $100 for 90 minutes of "service" and he challenged me on the tip, at the table, in front of my guests. Then complained to my guests and pointed at my face, stating that he wanted to talk "man to man". Management stood aside and let this happen. Antics like this have no place in a restuarant. Worst restaurant experience in my life. I don't recommend this place to anyone! Pros: Near Times Square Cons: , Management inaction more
Reply | Report abuse |

Just Wonderful! 4/1/2004

I always recommend this restaurant to friends and visitors, even if they're not going to the theater. The staff is always pleasant and quite attentive. I once took a group of 18 (with a reservation), ordered almost everything off the menu to share, and everyone loved everything - there were NO leftovers! So far, I've recommended TT about 7 times and I have yet to have a dissatisfied customer. What's also great is that it's quite reasonable, especially the pasta dishes, and the portions are ample. Pros: Quality of Food, Attentive Service, Reasonable Pricing more
Reply | Report abuse |

Decent meal, good location 4/1/2004

Dropped in without a reservation at 5:30pm. We were seated immediately. Staff was busy but attentive. Food wasn't spectacular, but pretty good. Wife had lasagna and commented 'too much cheese on top'. I had a tortellini dish which was pretty good. Ceasar salad dressing was too thin and croutons were stale. Dessert of tiramisu was good. Pros: Friendly staff, Location more
Reply | Report abuse |

Very Friendly 3/18/2004

We came from the LA area for a weekend in NY. We discovered this from Citysearch, and the ratings were right. The food was excellent and they had a lot of reasonably priced good Italian wines. We loved our server. We'd go back, but its 2500 miles away. Pros: Great Food, Warm Atmosphere more
Reply | Report abuse |

Charming Theatre Dist Italian 12/27/2003

Though somewhat small and cramped, the wonderful food and spectacular service make this a cut above other nearby Italian fare. The dessert cart is to die and the staff is friendly and attentive. You can't go wrong with this one and it's a bargain to boot! Pros: Yummy food, attentive staff, location Cons: cramped quarters more
Reply | Report abuse |

going out of their way 8/2/2003

Early evening dinner with my 3 year old grandaughter, son and daughter in law. We arrived with a mcdonald's milk shake that my grandaughter would not give up. We were willing to throw it away, this wonderful staff wouldnt hear of it and made her feel special by putting it in a "glass like ours" therefore making everyone happy. Did I mention the food is excellent. I go there every time I am in NYC. I am never disappointed. Sincerly, L.Dennis Ocean City Md. more
Reply | Report abuse |

The Tiramisu is Worth Missing Your Show 6/19/2003

I read the other positive reviews, so I had to check it out...and they were right on. You can not go wrong with any dish, however, the Veal Sorentino could potentially be the best in the city! The staff is certainly friendly, and the prices are phenominal. Also, the creativeness behind their daily specials is brilliant! An A+ all around. Pros: Food, Service, Decor Cons: There is only one more
Reply | Report abuse |

Hidden Treasure 1/25/2003

For what it tries to accomplish--provide "tasty food", with great service at reasonable prices--there is no finer place in NYC. All around a tremendous place to grab a great lunch or dinner! Pros: Service, Taste, Management more
Reply | Report abuse |

AMAZING PLACE 1/20/2003

This is the best place to go! Amazing service, delicious homemade food, very reasonable. I would recommend this to everyone!!! The calamari fritti melt in your mouth and make sure you save room for dessert because the Chocolate Mousse Cake is to die for!!!!!! Definitely need to try it out! more
Reply | Report abuse |

Great Food Great Service Great Price 1/16/2003

We we seated right away. The service was great. The food was great. The tiramisu was amazing! It was reasonably priced. I would go to this resturant again and again.! more
Reply | Report abuse |

Great choice 12/18/2002

The service was great, the food was terrific, the atmosphere was nice, and the value beyond belief. To find a great reasonably priced Italian restaurant in the theater district was fantastic. We will definitely eat here again. more
Reply | Report abuse |

My favorite! 12/11/2002

I LOVE this place! I think it's romantic and cozy and a truly terrific restaurant. No matter what I order, it's always delicious and their tiramisu is not to be missed! more
Reply | Report abuse |
< Previous 1 2 3 Next >
Menu for Trattoria Trecolori


Summer SALE!!!:
15% OFF all yearly plans
Use year15 at checkout. Expires 1/1/2021
Editorial

  • This popular Theater District destination for homey Italian fare has relocated to new digs.

  • 5/23/2007 Provided by Citysearch
Additional information
  • Hours: Sun-Thu 12pm-10:30pm Fri-Sat 12pm-11:15pm
  • Payments: Master Card, Diner's Club, American Express, Visa, Discover
  • Neighborhoods: Midtown, Theater District - Times Square
badge