JavaScript is not enabled.
The Melrose Hotel - New York, NY - Reviews page 1 - Judysbook

The Melrose Hotel

Claim
marker
140 E 63rd St
New York, NY 10021
marker
(646) 381-2675
Incorrect info? Correct your listing

Main categories:

Hotels & Lodging

Related categories:

Travel & Transportation

Reviews

( 2 )
( 3 )
( 0 )
( 2 )
( 1 )

Best

We had the best experience, right near Madison Ave, the rooms are newly renovated and we realized that we had stayed there when it was the Barbazon! It was a nice trip and the st...

Worst

when we arrived we were put ito a Queen bed room when we had booked a king room. The Queen room measured 10' by 12""(no joke) and it took them a day to move us. They mad no adjust...

Great Service and Nice Locale 4/19/2005

I went expecting average and recieved great service . It's location is within walking distance of good food and entertainment . The concierge, Anya , is awesome ! give the lady a raise .One quick phone call each afternoon got us dinner at ""212"" , reserved seats at Dangerfields and theater tix . On the block we found a great 5 dollar breakfast and a 7 dollar lunch . It is 20 blocks from Times Sqaure , but in NYC terms that is only a 30 min walk . 3 blocks from Central Park , Ten blocks from the Met Museum . If shopping is your pleasure you are only 2 blocks from Madison Ave. , Park Ave. and 5th Ave. We will go back ! . Pros: service, locale, concierge Cons: bar, breakfast more

poor facility:poor performance 12/6/2004

when we arrived we were put ito a Queen bed room when we had booked a king room. The Queen room measured 10' by 12""(no joke) and it took them a day to move us. They mad no adjustment on the price and were quite rude. On the plus side, they have an ample number of elevators and the neighborhood is great. Next time, I'll look for a better hotel nearby! Pros: neighborhood, elevators Cons: , rude staff more

Nice & Comfortable 4/7/2003

The rooms are clean and the bathrooms are faily large. The room I stayed in had a corner terrace and the view was very nice. The area is great too - right near Bloomingdale's and diesel, zaras, banane republic, gap and express. more

Not Worth the Stress 2/23/2003

Arrived at hotel at 6pm on check-in date and our room was not ready. Hotel offered to upgrade us but only to a smoking room. We would have to wait 45 min. for a non-smoking room (with no upgrade). We had an hour to get ready before heading out to a play, so we spoke to the manager who only offered us a drink at the bar. Only after we pressed the issue did he offer us an upgrade to a non-smoking room (guess they had one afterall) but only for the first night. After half an hour spent sorting this out our original non-smoking room was ready. We were offered nothing for all the stress and inconvenience. The room was terrible (tiny with only a double bed and paper-thin walls). We complained further the next day and, finally (for a fee) were able to upgrade to a normal room. Pros: good location Cons: bad service, small rooms more

Great Find, Lots of Fun 9/18/2002

We had the best experience, right near Madison Ave, the rooms are newly renovated and we realized that we had stayed there when it was the Barbazon! It was a nice trip and the staff was helpful. Pros: Great Staff, Location, Nice Beds more

Perfect location 9/3/2002

The Melrose Hotel was perfect. Great prices, perfect location and terrific ammenities. Staff was very accomadating and extremely helpful. Didn't have to go to far because everything was nearby. Walking distance from great dining and perfect for shopping. The museums were only a quick cab ride away. I will be back!! Pros: location, price, fitness center more

Barn Yard Room 6/20/2002

This hotel really sucked!!! My room was tiny and looked like a cape cod some thing or other, white shutters and bad bedspread.The only good thing was the area everything else felt like a bad discount hotel. more

Nice new look and feel 5/28/2002

The Melrose provided me with everything that I was looking for. Through a special promotion that I found my wife and I ended up staying at the hotel for less than $200. The rooms were comfortable and the service was great. Next time I return to New York I will make sure to make another reservation at the Melrose. Pros: Gym next door, price, great rooms more
< Previous 1 Next >
HOLIDAY DISCOUNT :
15% OFF all yearly plans
Use YEAR15 at checkout. Expires 12/31/2016

Editorial

  • Twenty-two floors of classically elegant rooms and suites on the Upper East Side, some with whirlpool tubs, full entertainment centers.

  • 5/3/2005 Provided by Citysearch

Additional information

  • Neighborhoods:

    Midtown, Lenox Hill, Upper East Side

Best Deals and Recommendations