JavaScript is not enabled.
The Fishery - East Rockaway, NY - Reviews page 1 - Judysbook

The Fishery

Claim
marker
1 Main St
East Rockaway, NY 11518
marker
(516) 256-7117
Incorrect info? Correct your listing

Reviews

( 0 )
( 0 )
( 1 )
( 3 )
( 0 )

Best

All reviews seem negative

Worst

The waitress asked me if the food was bad? So I replied, I did'nt say that the food was bad I just saying I did't like it. Had the Bisque or shall I say a can of cambells cream of...

OVERALL...PRETTY GREAT!!! 1/30/2014

FIRST OFF, THE FOOD IS GREAT..THE PLACE INSIDE IS IMMACULATE. OUTDOOR RESTROOMS ARE AWFUL!! USE THE INDOORS!! ONLY ONE TOILET PER LADIES AND MENS ROOM...THIS PLACE REALLY NEEDS MORE BATHROOMS INSIDE! PRICES ARE OKAY..PORTIONS LARGE... THE BEST BANDS COME ON IN THE EVENING...AVOID THE EARLIER BANDS LIKE THE 3PM SHOWS THEY ARE AWFUL!!! SAW THE MAYBERRYS..ROCK CANDY...THE PROJECT...MAIN STREET--ALL WERE PRETTY BORING/BAD!! LATER BANDS SUCH AS DOWN & DIRTY, GENERATIONS..WERE GREAT!!! HAS A MIXED AGE CROWD THAT WILL APPEAL TO EVERYONE...WARNING!!! PARKING LOT IS TREACHEROUS DUE TO SMALL PEBBLES!!!! LADIES DO NOT WEAR SUPER HIGH HEELS!!!--ALSO THE OUTSIDE DECK IS VERY VERY SLIPPERY!!! SAW A REALLY HOT YOUNG GIRL TAKE A TERRIBLE FALL HERE WHEN THE GENERATIONS BAND PLAYED HERE IN JUNE!!! GIRL WAS INJURED..WE MENTIONED THIS TO THE STAFF---SO BE WARNED!! more

Editorial review from Citysearch 6/20/2012

The waitress asked me if the food was bad? So I replied, I did'nt say that the food was bad I just saying I did't like it. Had the Bisque or shall I say a can of cambells cream of tomato with little little bits of unknown seafood substance. My cousin had the East Rockaway Chowder and felt the stock was warmed up swamp water from the outside canal.The wife had the seared tuna salad and had to look real hard to find the tuna. I had the ""Fish & Chip""--How can I describe---How bout ""Mrs. Pauls"" enough said. The Hostesses were not exactly diner friendly and did not have a good handle on the turnover of their tables.The place offers live music on their deck complete with bar and outside dineing. But who wants to ruin their appetites watching drunk delusional geriactrics fantasize that they are 22 years old listening to mucisians wha are even older. I must say that our waiterss was very nice and professional and delivered excellent service. more

the fishery east rockaway 9/27/2011

food good bartender keith bother woman tries to pick up every girl in place rude lousy service at bar but food good more

Eh! 10/23/2010

Nothing special, just a fair restaurant, I can't say that I loved it because I didn't. But I didn't dislike it either. I think that they need to bring in a new and exciting up to date menu. more

Great Ambiance 11/19/2009

The food is very good and the atmosphere is very pleasant. You get to choose from a large menu and the wait staff is friendly and easy to reach when you need something. however, the price is high, although most places that serve fish are high, I am comparing it to Peter's Clam Bar in Island Park and Peters is not only less expensive, the food is better. To be fair, i have also eatten at Bigalow's in Oceanside and The Fishery blows them away! Pros: Good Food Great Atmosphere Cons: The Price more
< Previous 1 Next >

Menu for The Fishery




HOLIDAY DISCOUNT :
15% OFF all yearly plans
Use YEAR15 at checkout. Expires 12/31/2016

Additional information

  • Hours:

    Mon: 11:30A - 10:00P Tues: 11:30A - 10:00P Wed: 11:30A - 10:00P Thurs: 11:30A - 10:00P Fri: 11:30A - 11:00P Sat: 11:30A - 11:00P Sun: 11:30A - 10:00P
  • Neighborhoods:

    East Patchogue, Long Island City, Long Island

Best Deals and Recommendations