JavaScript is not enabled.
Talarico's Pizzeria - Seattle, WA - Reviews page 1 - Judysbook

Talarico's Pizzeria

4718 California Ave Sw
Seattle, WA 98116
(206) 937-3463
Incorrect info? Correct your listing


Talarico's Pizzeria - Seattle, WA


( 23 )
( 7 )
( 4 )
( 4 )
( 6 )


best late night food in west seattle, good drinks, cool bartenders (even though they are a little on the douchy side) theres no better place to go on a week night in west seattle,...


Wish this place was still the old Chinese restaurant. \r \r As far as restraurants go, the menu is very limited and every time I've been there (which is more than 1/2 dozen time...

great spot 4/23/2011

best late night food in west seattle, good drinks, cool bartenders (even though they are a little on the douchy side) theres no better place to go on a week night in west seattle, if you havn't.. go there. more

Good thin crust pizzas 3/6/2011

Anything with more than two types of meat would be too much. The Kauai is delicious. Brownie dessert is to die for. Pizzas are big, but thin crust, so it's perfectly filling. HH prices look awesome, but I've never been able to make it. Maybe next time. more

LOVE this place! 11/15/2010

Really surprised with all the mixed reviews. Just there this Friday, live jazz and great ambience! Honestly, the food is consistently fantastic and the service has always been great! more

Agree with No Quality...All Quantity 10/1/2010

Bland food and too much of it. Not to mention rude employees who don't seem to care what you think. Place is so dark you have to wonder what they are trying to hide. Unless this is the only place open in West Seattle don't waste your time. more

Biggest slice in the world 3/8/2010

I'm seriously still overwhelmed by ""Biggest slice in the world"" so much so that it's all I can think to say right now. The pro was how can you complain about a huge ass slice of pizza for only $6? The con came in that I wanted so badly to fold it (I'm from NY, we must fold our slices) and I did, but it was so big the end fell under the weight & I had to start with a fork (this is pizza sacrilege for us NY'ers). I actually really liked the vibe of the place, it was very comfy and easy to talk amongst our large group (until exactly 9pm when the music was turned up to nightclub volume). The bar is pretty cool, it takes up about 1/3 of the whole place. Definitely wear your contacts if you want to get a good look at the dudes (or gals) across the bar, it's seriously far all the way to the other side. Good pizza, great service, cool vibe, I'd be happy to go back. Pros: Biggest slice in the world Cons: Biggest slice in the world more

Nice Improvements 12/28/2009

I've been going to Talarico's since it opened. The service has sometimes been inconsistent, but the last few months I've seen some BIG improvements. The food quality is up and the crew seems better trained. It's my new old favorite place to hang. Pros: Great Pizza and good pours more

No Quality...All quantity 7/6/2009

If you like hanging out in a dark and dingy room eating really bad pizza, served by really bad people, surrounded by really horrendous drunks, then this is your place. Not a place I'd ever bring my kids. The gimmick with the pizza is that it is large, so that is what people talk about, not the quality. Management seems to be asleep at this place. There's so many quality places in West Seattle, that it's easy to pass this place up. Cons: Bad food, no quality more


We were recomended to Talarico's by a friend and were not disappointed. \r Just like the other reviewers we loved the dim lighting and open fireplaces at tables. \r It was extremely nice that they made our kids feel welcome too, and being a lounge we didnt feel the need to keep them quiet; which can be difficult at times.\r There salad and artichoke dip were both fresh, delicious and equally pleasing to the eye. \r We also had one of their seasonal unfiltered beers. I was surprised as I do not often like lighter beers, but it had the perfect balance of hops hops and smoothness.\r As per our servers recomendation we did not order a full pizza (measuring 28"" across) but opted for getting a a slice a piece. As I am bias to Waterfront pizza in port townsend. Their pizza was amazingly good with just the right combination of toppings and crust the was crisp but not overcooked.\r we ended with their skillet cookie dessert which was served in a cast iron pan still sizzling hot when brought to the table and topped with a heaping scoop of vanilla icecream. Despite not heeding the servers warning we all burned ourselves on the pan as we were fighting for the last bites of the dessert.\r Not only does Talarico's not disappoint with their food, I couldnt have asked for a better wait staff. Pros: Best service. great ambience, great food across the board, great beer. more

Good rep...I think not 12/31/2008

I have heard nothing but good things about Talarico's . So I go there to get some awesome pizza with a couple of buddies and once we took a step in the door, everything went wrong. I just turned 21 only a few months ago, so everywhere I go I want to get a beer. I still have a vertical license, and I got harassed by the waitress about it. Then when we go to order food, we all get a slice of pizza each(which are ginormous) and it takes nearly 45 minutes for us to get it. I mean, how hard is it to make 3 slices of pizza; and the place was only half full. I mean, the place wasn't even busy. I am very disappointed in this place and don't recommend. Horrible service! Pros: Food Cons: Service more

What happened to this place? 11/20/2008

...this used to be one of the best places to hang out in WS but the last six months have been nothing but one painful experience after another...every time I go in there there is a sea of new faces working there and the service just gets worse and guess it was either an owner or a management change...but whatever it was it's not working at all...and what's this I hear about kids? They can kiss my entertainment dollars goodbye... Cons: service, management, staff more

great pizza, good drinks when you can get one***parking???? 8/10/2008

I was there on a Saturday night, my girlfriend and i were having a great time at first. Then we could't find our waiter. He started off giving great service then we didn't see him for awhile. No big deal I had cash so i went to the bar to order us more drinks. While i was at the bar there was our waiter TAKING A SHOT!!! What BS I was waiting for a drink and he was having one. \r I still recommend Talaricos, but you might want to order a double or plan on a wait.\r Pros: great pizza we really enjoyed the south street more

Love,love...KIDS???? 6/17/2008

The rumor mill is churning a most disturbing one folks. Kids aloud in the bar until 9 PM. The coolness factor will dispurse and myself and my partner shall start taking our friends down the street to West Five. They still only cateer to the adult crowd and greed has not set hold of them. Talaricos is always packed with a great crowd and even better great food,drinks and bartenders. I hope the kids rumor is just that... a rumor, or I will have to day that all good things must come to a end. more

Best Pizza & Happy Hour in West Seattle 4/29/2008

I've been to Talarico's dozens of times and always experienced good service. The pizza is delicious and they poor a solid drink. The crowd is mixed with different ages and races, which makes for a great atmosphere. Their sports coverage is awesome. more

Great pizza! 4/23/2008

Really good pizza. \r maybe some more menu options? Went to go dancing and was told by the DJ they don't play any 'urban' music. I wasn't asking for Too Short. Come on??? Pros: pizza & the kareokee is fun Cons: D.J. music more

Good concept with terrible service 4/9/2008

Wish this place was still the old Chinese restaurant. \r \r As far as restraurants go, the menu is very limited and every time I've been there (which is more than 1/2 dozen times), they are sold out several items. Not an imaginitve or expansive drink list either. I'd opt for Paggliacci's any day over the Talaricos pizza. \r \r This would all be forgiveable if the service wasn't terrible. Yikes. Worst experienced in all of West Seattle-- slow, not trained or educated on food or beverage, and with an attitidue. I'd rather spend my money somewhere with a smile. Pros: Good location with some off street parking nearby Cons: Horrible service, bad menu selection, overpriced more

Definitely going back 3/27/2008

The only time that I'm ever in West Seattle is for business. So I'm there during the week and I can't say that I stay out past 8:30 to 9:00 pm. But one place I love in this town is Talaricos. I'm no expert on New York pizza but as far as pizza joints in the Northwest go, this place is terrific. Great place to grab a beer and enjoy a slice. There are many reports of this place having bad service but that has not been the case for me. Each time I've been there the service has been excellent. However, the thing that I always look for in a new place is the atmosphere. And this place's atmosphere fits it's style very well. Keep it up Talaricos! Pros: Good food, Great atmosphere Cons: Parking is a drag more

A Pizza and brew place that tries to be a... 3/14/2008

A Pizza and brew place that tries to be a little more. You can get a decent antipasto here, or even a plate... more

I love this place! 2/10/2008

Ok. I don't know about these other ppl that have been giving bad reviews. but i've been going to Talarico's for almost a yr now. I go just about every weekend with my friends and we always have a great time. We always have great service no matter whos section we sit in...Although we have our prefered section we sometimes get a different server. Even if we sit at the bar our experience is awesome. I would recomend it to anyone. I've even had my birthday there....and they treated me awesome...our server even sang me a birthday song. The food is awesome, the drinks are great! Pros: Great Service awesome food Cons: parking more

not just pizza 1/28/2008

I was so happy this past weekend. I tried to call to share my joy with the management but nobody answered the phone. The hostess sat us at the bar friday night. The bartender informed us about the specials and we tried the polenta. It was fantastic. She had mentioned that you guys were going to have specials every weekend. I'm looking forward to see whats next. Pros: fast and friendly service Cons: parking more

Kudos to Talaricos 1/17/2008

I came in last night for triva with some friends and had a great time!! The pizza was fabulous, as usual. And I'm surprised to see some of the other bad reviews. Our server was delightful, and funny. We'll be back next week. Keep up the good work. Kudos to the kitchen staff as well. We know you're working hard back there. more
< Previous 1 2 3 Next >

Menu for Talarico's Pizzeria

15% OFF all yearly plans
Use YEAR15 at checkout. Expires 11/30/2016


  • The Scene
    The noirish atmosphere is set when patrons enter through a heavy wooden door and let their eyes slowly adjust to the low lighting. Seating is available for every occasion and...

  • 11/15/2006 Provided by Citysearch

Additional information

  • Hours:

    Mon-Fri 4pm-2am Sat, Sun 11am-2am
  • Neighborhoods:

    West Seattle, Junction

Best Deals and Recommendations