The Squire is a classic barbershop with a small town feel. It's got a great location at Grand and Snelling too, right across from Macalester College! LOVE that area. (Student discounts, college folks!)
The three barbers that work there are good guys who remember your name, tell jokes, chat, and make it a fun experience. No, they don't have the cheapest prices, but I go there for the atmosphere as much as the hair cut. It just feels comfortable there. I've had all three guys cut my hair at some point over the last 12-13 years or so, and they all do a great job, but Michael is the one I see regularly. He's outstanding. I recommend The Squire highly!