JavaScript is not enabled.
Soul Fixins - New York, NY - Reviews page 1 - Judysbook

Soul Fixins

Claim
marker
225 W 28th St
New York, NY 10001
marker
(212) 736-1345
Incorrect info? Correct your listing

Reviews

( 6 )
( 5 )
( 3 )
( 1 )
( 4 )

Best

Delicious Oxtail, Macaroni and potato salad. Will order again!!!

Worst

I'm perplexed by the rave reviews. Either people haven't been down South or were glad to see an eatery in an empty area. As someone from GA, I felt the sides were mediocre at best...

Editorial review from GrubHub 2/24/2014

if i could give negative stars i would more

Editorial review from GrubHub 11/14/2013

Delivery time was great and price was very reasonable. Now the food on the other hand was awful I wish I could have given it a negative star. I ordered the whiting with yams and green beans and a slice of sweet potato pie. It came in a tiny container and everything was all together so the fish was tough and wet at the same time. The yams really weren't sweet and was covered with juice from the green beans. The green beans were vinegary and brown. The sweet potato pie was awful to the point of explanatory. Oh and the cornbread was tough and rubbery. more

Editorial review from GrubHub 11/10/2013

Delicious Oxtail, Macaroni and potato salad. Will order again!!! more

Editorial review from GrubHub 10/14/2013

I've had better. Mediocre at best. more

Editorial review from GrubHub 9/17/2013

Food was unbelievable. Great food the ox tail just falls off the bone and the cabbage is terrific. Delivery was quick and accurate. I will definitely go back and recommend it to everyone. 5 out of 5 star . more


everything was just Okay 2/21/2011

the lemonade was great.... but nothing impressive other than that! I don't think I will go back again! I will visit Amy Ruth's if I want to have good soul food!! more

This Place is CLOSED!! 4/17/2009

Went to check it out and it was ""Retail Space For Lease"" Just when I thought I was getting Fish and Grits :o( Pros: Wish I could tell you Cons: Wish I could tell you more

Another just good Soul Food place 7/11/2008

When it comes to finding soul food, Soul Fixins fills the Garment District void. The service is great, friendly chefs and servers. The place is small and too bad there's no park nearby to sit & eat. The food is good, though definitely no-frills. No hoopin and hollerin over finding out the recipe, and the portion of BBQ chicken was a little on the skimpy side. I would go back again, though, since it's close to me and I cannot find food like this (for this price and short wait time) in this area. Pros: Good collards, meatloaf, chicken, yams in a rare area; parking; hospitality; no wait time Cons: Tiny restaurant, sometimes no place to sit more


That's why Fixes your Soul! 8/30/2007

This Place worth traveing from Italy to NYC. Pros: All Cons: N/A more

Loved it! 5/24/2006

Granted, I'm not an expert on soul food (this was probably the first time I've eaten it), but I thought everything here was really delicious!! The okra was probably my favorite. Very tasty. Second is the chicken smothered in gravy, the cornbread and the macaroni and cheese. I don't normally like mac & cheese, but this stuff was good. The sweet potatoes weren't really to my liking. I think I'm not used to that spice they put in it. Probably the best part of this restaurant was the guy behind the counter. He was so helpful. He even let us taste the side dishes because we were undecided on them. The ambience isn't 5-star, but I think it really suits the place. Loved it!! Definitely going back again. Pros: awesome food, great service Cons: can't think of any more

Soul Fixmeup Some More~ 9/10/2005

Get your Fix for Southern, cafeteria style soul food, where the prices are cheap and the food is delicious. The service has always been very nice and polite during all hours of operation. Not recommended for big groups as the place is super small. Pros: Food, Prices Cons: Small more

DEE-LISH-OUS!!! :) 10/7/2004

Me and some of my co workers were in the mood for some Soul food and I checked this website out to get some reviews on some places. Soul Fixins got a lot of great reviews and after trying there food today, I say they definitely deserve the praise. Now, I can't tell u how the restaurant and ambiance is because this was a delivery but the food was DELICIOUS. Soul Fixins JUUUST became my new Soul Food spot! :) Pros: Inexpensive, Prompt Delivery, Wonderful Food more

Awesome! 9/27/2003

Despite the post below, I just moved here from Virginia, and I thought that the food was quite authentic. Everything that I had was fresh, moist, and perfectly seasoned. The meatloaf, macaroni and cheese, collards, and green beans were particularly delicious. Their friendly and helpful service, reasonable prices, and generous portions will keep me coming back for more. (And they deliver!) Pros: great food, reasonable prices, friendly service Cons: limited seating, not much atmosphere more

NYC style ""southern food"" 5/10/2003

I'm perplexed by the rave reviews. Either people haven't been down South or were glad to see an eatery in an empty area. As someone from GA, I felt the sides were mediocre at best, and not seasoned authentically at all. I give props to their fish only since it's something they cook fresh. Good size servings, but the price isn't worth the quality or service. This is a no-table-service cafeteria-style shop with most items premade for you to point-select. Although most Southern dishes must be premade, their food was dry from sitting in the trays. Not much to say about the counter people's service since they just plate the food and hand it over, but I suppose they aren't needlessly rude. Overall, if you're in the neighborhood and need a quick bite, fine, but if you're looking for real and good Southern food, this is not worth your trip. Pros: Fast, Filling, Decent taste Cons: Overpriced, Not authentic, Not fresh enough more

Beware of Food Coma! 2/6/2003

I saw Soul Fixins' on Foodtv and decided to give it a try. The store is a small place but the food is amazing! The candied yams are soo sweet, chicken and dumplings are yummy. The price is very reasonable. The only con about the place is that it doesn't have enough tables so it gets crowded very easily. I've been there twice so far and plan to go back for more. more

Love it! 11/13/2002

This is one of the best soul food places in the city! The mac n cheese speaks for itself, and being a regular I always go for the smothered chicken and greens! Potato salad is the bomb as well! Try it and you'll love it as much as everyone else on here! Not much seating but the food is worth waiting to sit or get take out! Pros: great food, nice staff, convenient Cons: busy, lack of seating, wait in line more

Mmm Mmm Good! 8/27/2002

There isn't any word to describe how tasty the food is. I had the fried whiting with macaroni and cheese, and my beau had smothered chicken and greens. The helpings were so plentiful that we could barely walk out of there.....and DELICIOUS! more

My arteries are gleefully slamming shut 7/24/2002

Soul Fixin's has the ambience of a college-town coffeehouse and the lard-soaked ecstasy of a home-cooked meal in the deep South. The meatloaf and chicken are always amazing, but what makes this place truly special are the sides. I don't know what the secret ingredient in the collard greens is, but they were phenomenal. Pros: great food, fast service Cons: little ambience, heavy, unhealthy food more
< Previous 1 2 Next >

Menu for Soul Fixins




HOLIDAY DISCOUNT :
15% OFF all yearly plans
Use YEAR15 at checkout. Expires 12/31/2016

Editorial

  • The Scene
    There's nothing fancy about this small soul food spot near Madison Square Garden--which the pre-event crowd and older regulars think is just fine. The tables are few, the carpet...

  • 10/16/2007 Provided by Citysearch

Additional information

  • Hours:

    Monday 11:00 AM - 9:30 PM Tuesday 11:00 AM - 9:30 PM Wednesday 11:00 AM - 9:30 PM Thursday 11:00 AM - 9:30 PM Friday 11:00 AM - 9:30 PM Saturday 4:00 PM - 9:00 PM Sunday Closed
  • Payments:

    Master Card, American Express, Discover, Visa
  • Neighborhoods:

    Garment District, Midtown, Chelsea

Best Deals and Recommendations