JavaScript is not enabled.
Sicily Pizza - Nashville, TN - Reviews page 1 - Judysbook

Sicily Pizza

Claim
marker
3610 Anderson Rd
Nashville, TN 37217
marker
(615) 365-0009
Incorrect info? Correct your listing

Main categories:

Restaurants , Pizza Restaurants

Related categories:

Food & Dining

Reviews

( 13 )
( 0 )
( 0 )
( 2 )
( 5 )

Best

My wife and I have been going to this pizza shop since moving over to this area about 6 years ago.\r Better than ANY chain delivery and they know the regulars by name. At lunch,...

Worst

The people leaving good reviews about this place haven't had real pizza or their lying because this is the one and only time we tried their pizza and the last also. It just doesn'...

One of the best undiscovered Pizza Gems in Nashville 1/31/2010

My wife and I have been going to this pizza shop since moving over to this area about 6 years ago.\r Better than ANY chain delivery and they know the regulars by name. At lunch, there is always a crowd of delivery people (USPS, UPS, FedEx, etc) stopping in to eat.\r \r Always HOT upon pick-up and stays that way until you get home. We usually have to recut it, because the cheese has melted back together on the slices.\r \r Give it a shot sometime. You won't regret it. Pros: GREAT TASTING PIZZA!!! Great Price & value Cons: No Delivery...But worth the trip down the street. more

DON'T BELIEVE THE BAD REVIEWS 7/6/2009

OK.....don't believe the 1-star reviews which smell conspicuously like a competitor just trying to pull their score down.\r \r This place has authenic NY-Syle pizza that tastes great and is made with fresh ingredients. I eat here at least twice a month. Pros: Authentic NY Style Pizza ( I know I am a Yankee) Cons: No Delivery more

They Care About their Food and Customers 100% 6/15/2009

I have been to this place since they opened the business here. Knew the family when they opened their first Sicily Pizza account at the bank with me. I can tell you, the owner and people that work there, DO care about the food, a lot. It's not a bunch of packaged frozen food thrown in boiling water. They make thier sauces, even their meatballs. Take a date there and sit down. It's small but the food is incredible. The Calzones are huge and way too affordable for how good they are. Get the house salad with the Hot Garlic bread to start. The house dressing is delicious and Yes, your breath will smell but it doesn't matter, You'll see why. Try this little place once or carry out. Don't listen to these bad reviews because they are lying or are just competing. You don't have to go here all the time. For me, I go there when I want to reward myself for something I accomplished or I want to surprise my date. You don't have to worry about breaking the bank everytime you eat and you will be satisfied. I can tell you, the owner and the cooks would never write some of the stuff on here like these bad reviews. All they care about is you enjoyed what they made. That is honest and a fact. I won't say they have the best pizza because everyone make theres a little different. I can't stop ordering the calzones or the pasta to compare all the other pizzas to theirs. Pros: BEST CALZONE EVER AND INEXPENSIVE! Cons: It's small if eating in but It's about the food really more

Best Pizza and Subs 4/25/2009

The best pizza in Nashville.A nice little place. Very clean.\r Great service.The prices are very good.They have a great $5 lunch deal. You are in and out fast. Pros: Nice Family Place more

it's terrible 3/30/2009

The people leaving good reviews about this place haven't had real pizza or their lying because this is the one and only time we tried their pizza and the last also. It just doesn't taste too good. Plain and simple Cons: awful more

Best pizza in Nashville by far! 2/19/2009

If you love NY pizza, this is the place to go! Mouth watering layers of cheese, delicious Italian sauce, and the perfect crust consistancy...I'm actually ordering for dinner tonight. I would HIGHLY recommend the round pizza vs. the sheet pizza (wasn't a fan at all of the sheet style). There are great deals on the weekends, ex: double cheese, double pepperoni large for $12.99 and the leftovers even taste delicious heated up the next day. YUMMY....try it yourself! more

repeat offender 1/12/2009

This proves that anyone cab leave as many reviews as they like. U had a feeling because u read five very bad and ridiculous reviews about this place when I live right next to it and eat there once a week and ok e their pizza. Which makes me believe it must be a competitor trying to screw with their good rating. When a place has average 4 stars and then you see 5 one star reviews in a row saying the same dumb thing... It has competitor written all over it. This is my FAV place to eat and I get steamed when this happens. Because I know they are luring which makes the true rating false. This place rocks more

Screw Up To-Go Orders! 12/24/2008

My family has not been too impressed with the service we have received from Sicily Pizza. Multiple times they have messed up our to-go orders, which is a huge pain in the butt. It takes a long time to be served, and once when I went to eat there with a friend and our children, the female owner stared us down every time our kids were loud. Kinda rude! Pros: Cheap lunch menu. Lot's of $5 options. Cons: The owner seems to hate kids. Food is slow. Orders are often messed up. more

bad air 3/11/2008

This place smelled like someone let some bad air out of their corn hole. It smelled like their was alot of bad air in the atmosphere that came out of someone's corn launcher. The pizza tastes like ----. My grandaughter could make better pizza then theirs. She is only 7 years old. This place is terrible! Pros: I was holding my breath Cons: The air smelled like it came out of someones corn hole and the pizza is awfull more

SPEND YOUR MONEY SOMEWHERE ELSE 3/6/2008

I've eaten at pretty much all the pizza places in nashville but this was on the bottom of my list. The dough was stale and hard to chew. I was starving but only ate one piece and threw what was left of a large away and then just made a quick sandwich. I called them and informed them of this pizza but they didn't really seem to care. I guess there used to this and know how bad there pizza is. I'll never eat there again. Pros: I only ate one piece Cons: I had to make a sandwich becuase I threw the rest away. They wouln't help me. more

unpleasin 3/6/2008

I wouldn't eat this pizza again if someone put a gun to my head. I think the frozen Kroger's pizza brand is alot better than this stuff. It tasted like dirt was in it or something. Pros: Thumbs down to this pizza that tastes like dirt Cons: I warned you more

Do Not Eat It!!!!! 2/13/2008

Awful pizza. The sauce is the worst. Don't eat it. It made my stomach hurt. The only reason I gave it a star is because the woman working there was cute. Pros: Cute woman working here Cons: Bad food more

Worst pizza and subs in the world! 1/23/2008

Absolutely the worst pizza in the world. The dough isn't fresh at all. Don't get there subs because they don't put any ingredients on them. Its a big rip off. All the good reviews you see about this place have to be written by the owners of this place to try to get business. I know one thing. I would never buy there pizza again. Save your money and go to the new china restaurant next door instead. Pros: I wont waste my money here any more Cons: Worst pizza and subs in the world more

Nashville's best keep secret. 5/2/2007

On a Friday night it is the place to eat. You get the best tasting food for very little. They have a wonderful atmosphere. it's like a little slice of Italy in our corner of the world. They have the best staff always friendly and smiling. This is going to sound chessey but they know our names and know exactly what we like. I have recommended this restaurant to many different people and they have all thanked me for telling them about it. Their five dollar lunch can't be beat. They have subs, pasta, and pizza the best in town.. Pros: The staff, food, and Price more

fantastic food and unparalled customer service 4/9/2007

Have been a customer for only a year, yet the waitstaff knows my voice before I even tell them on the phone when I call in my order !!!!!! Calzones are great, perfect blend of ingredients. Pizza is the best in this town that I have tried, and I lived in Chicago most of my life where pizza is like a religion....if you moved this\r place there, they would be serious contenders for number 1....atmosphere is great for dine in or take out,\r checkered table cloths, Italian decor....Peroni beer is a nice touch, too....prices for the amount of food you \r receive are very very good....the service though, is fantastic...even when the place is jammed on Friday\r nights, the hostess/waitress/cashier juggles it all with a smile....she is fantastic....I have traveled a lot and eaten at lots of places and never seen her equal.....all told, both thumbs way way up.... Pros: service,food and value all fantastic more

Best Pizza in Nashville, If you want local and want good taste, eat Sicily! 3/22/2007

So, I don't get out to the Bell Road, Hickory Hollow area to often, actually only a few times a year. But a few weeks ago I was out here and caught lunch at a small little pizza place, called Sicily's Pizza. It is off of Anderson Road and after one time, I was hooked. I love Pizza Perfect, pizza, but the other day, I was eating Pizza Perfect in Nashville, and found myself wishing that it had come from Sicily's. Not to knock Pizza Peffect I like them too. But I will tell you this, I have come to Hickory Hollow 4 times in the last three weeks, mainly to just catch a slice of Sicily's Pizza. If you want good pizza try this place. I had some tonight and I have a nice full stomach, so I thought I'd write in. Pros: Two Thumbs Way Up more

BEST PIZZA IN TENNESSEE OVERALL 3/10/2006

IF YOU WANT GREAT FOOD, FRIENDLIEST SERVICE,HOMECOOKING,AND FAMILY RAN THIS IS THE PLACE TO GO. I'VE NEVER BEEN ANYWHERE LIKE THIS EVERYBODY IS SO FRIENDLY AND MAKES YOU FEEL WELCOMED AND LIKE PART OF THE SICILY PIZZA FAMILY YOU COME BACK AGAIN AND AGAIN. OVERALL FROM THE FOOD TO THE SERVICE I RATE THIS OVER AND ABOVE EXCELLENT. Pros: INEXPENSIVE, SERVICE, QUALITY Cons: NONE, NONE, NONE more

From Sicily to Home 10/3/2004

This is one thr nicest and friendliest spots to walk into. If you were not born Sicilian they make you feel like you are. BILLY IS THE MAN. :-) You must go into this place. -BklynNYbunny Pros: Friendly, Great Food, Just the place to be more

excellent 7/30/2002

this is the best nieghborhood restuarant and everyone there is verynice..i am currently stationed in korea..but everytime i am home that is the first place i want to go to eat..Billy and Anna the owners make you feel at home and i miss them... love you guys!!! shannon ps i'll be home in october..so see you then more

succulent italian 7/18/2002

BEST ITALIAN FOOD EVER WITHOUT LEAVING TOWN!!!! MUST TASTE EVRYTHING!!!! ALMOST LIKE BEING IN A CAFE IN ITALY!!!! more
< Previous 1 Next >

Menu for Sicily Pizza




WINTER DISCOUNT :
15% OFF all yearly plans
Use YEAR15 at checkout. Expires 2/28/2017

Additional information

  • Payments:

    Master Card, American Express, Visa

Best Deals and Recommendations