We had a pleasant time at Shelly's, but it just wasn't worth the price. We were seated immediately, our server was top-notch, and the beer choices were good. We liked the wood motif and the big fireplace. The menu selections ranged from $15 for the specials to nearly $30 for a steak. The food was good, but not good enough for those prices. My husband's panfish special was basically fried fish and fries in a basket, and he was disappointed. My steak and our appetizer were good. However, for a total tab of $100, I would expect a tablecloth, REALLY good food, and want it to be less casual than shorts and t-shirts (which is what many people were wearing). If they cut their prices by 30%, I would recommend Shelly's in a minute, and would go back. But for these prices, I'd rather step out at Murray's or Jax.
Pros: Great Service!, Quick seating, Relaxed atmosphere
Cons: Food not worth price, Too casual for price