Shake It! Records has the most intelligent selection of music in Cincinnati. Their listening stations always have interesting and fun albums to sample, and their used CD collection is unbelievable. If you're addicted to vinyl, you'll find their downstairs section to have more than enough records to feed the beast. They have a great selection of new vinyl as well as the classic older stuff, including a really good jazz section. I go to Shake It! whenever I need to find something, or am just looking for something new.
Pros: Great vinyl selection, cool staff, interesting sample stations, huge used CD section