JavaScript is not enabled.
Scalini Fedeli - New York, NY - Reviews page 1 - Judysbook

Scalini Fedeli

Claim
marker
165 Duane St (at nr. Hudson St.)
New York, NY 10013
marker
(212) 528-0400
Incorrect info? Correct your listing

Photos

Scalini Fedeli - New York, NY
Scalini Fedeli - New York, NY
Scalini Fedeli - New York, NY
Scalini Fedeli - New York, NY
Scalini Fedeli - New York, NY
Scalini Fedeli - New York, NY
Scalini Fedeli - New York, NY
Scalini Fedeli - New York, NY

Reviews

( 11 )
( 7 )
( 4 )
( 2 )
( 0 )

Best

Great for special occasions. The chef/owner is extremely personable and makes his rounds reciting his recommendations. Throughout the meal we received several tastings compliments...

Worst

The food is undoubtedly good. But the meal was ruined when, moments after paying the $400 check, our waiter asked if we could leave because ""other patrons were waiting to sit dow...

Great food, but got kicked out by waiter 10/17/2009

The food is undoubtedly good. But the meal was ruined when, moments after paying the $400 check, our waiter asked if we could leave because ""other patrons were waiting to sit down."" It felt like a bucket of ice water had been poured on our table. We had been there for 2 hrs and 45 minutes, which is pretty typical for 3 people. When we asked to speak with the manager, the manager didn't apologize, he told us that other tables had been late, so they were backed up. Fine Dining? More like restaurant management for amateurs. Pros: Amazing Food Cons: Unwelcoming service, poor operations more

great customer service, small portioned food 10/25/2008

Went there for a birthday tonight and we must say the customer service was impeccable; however, for a dinner that cost $230 (tip and tax included), we expected larger portions. We ordered the chicken and swordfish dish. The portion of the swordfish was extremely small and came with approximately 5-6 gnocchi spread around the dish . Further, the chicken dish states that it is served over pasta and that was hardly the case. A few pieces were just spread around the chicken as well. The food was delicious but for such an expensive dinner we definitely were expecting to fill our appetites. We wouldn't go there again, as delicious food at larger protions can be found elsewhere at a MUCH better price. Overall, the tab seemed appropriate for the fancy/intimate decor, great service, but definitely not the food. Pros: excellent service, intimate environment, delicious food Cons: expensive for the small food portions served more

Worth the trip downtown and the money. 1/8/2008

Great for special occasions. The chef/owner is extremely personable and makes his rounds reciting his recommendations. Throughout the meal we received several tastings compliments of the chef. We were surprised by how many options there were for a price fix menu. And at $65 this wasnt a bad deal. Everything we had was delicious. We left extremely full. The space itself is beautiful: vaulted ceilings, candle lit tables and velvety chair covers. Most tables are well spaced so you dont feel cramped like in some restaurants. If you are looking to impress your date, spouse etc, then definitely make your way downtown to Scalini Fedeli. It exceeded our expectations. While we seldomly return to a restaurant, we will definitely be returning here.\r Pros: Service, Atmosphere, Food selection, Food taste, Chef Cons: In the middle of nowhere more

one of the best... 8/22/2007

I think this is the first time I have felt compelled to come on here and write a review. I don't know how I haven't been here before now. someone suggested it last night and I didn't know what they were talking about. I had never heard of the restaurant. but I looked it up and it looked great, so I made a reservation.\r \r sure enough, everything about last night was amazing. first of all, the number of choices on a prix fixe menu suprised me. probably the most I've seen. and even the things I don't like looked good the way they were put together. everything we ordered was beyond excellent. get the venison chop. seriously. we were also given a full extra first course (which the chef came out to explain), a tasting plate of a ravioli, and two extra dessert dishes. I don't know if that's because it was my girlfriend's birthday or just for the sake of it, but either way, it was very much appreciated (and good). her dessert came with a candle and a ""happy birthday"" message on the plate. the staff was all extremely friendly...not only to us, but to the tables around us. this is truly one of the best dining experiences I've had.\r \r I can't recommend the restaurant enough. Pros: everything. more

Great place for a very special occasion. 3/9/2007

I took my boyfriend here for his birthday dinner, and I definitely made the right pick. The service is probably the best I've ever had, and I've dined at a ton of five-star restaurants -- it's attentive without being overbearing and informative without seeming snooty. And then there's the food... it's really terrific... We were on cloud nine when we left. It's a perfect place for a romantic special occasion dinner. I would definitely go back. more

best italian 3/5/2007

Went for special evening and expected to pay extra, it was a little expensive but well worth it.The regular menu is a prix fixe so the food seemed to just keep coming.All the food was great and to finish they brought us these giant strawberries with cold zabaglione, after our dessert WOW!!! Pros: Service, food and decor all great Cons: A little pricey more

Wonderful decor, mediocre food 3/1/2007

The decor and lighting make the space feel intimate, fancy yet comfortable. It's the kind of place you want to take a loved one where you know the surroundings will make you feel like a special, intimate couple. But then the food comes out and negates the experience. I started with the spaghettini arrabiata and thought it simply mediocre. My main dish was the tuna, and that was an outright disappointment. The tuna itself was bland, and I thought that the sauces did not really complement the fish. It was as if the chef were trying too hard to come up with something inventive, but failed miserably. The other folks in our party also commented that their dishes did not stand out. On the positive side, the wait staff were excellent. The maitre d', however, was a troglodyte. His absence would have made our evening more enjoyable, but we were interrupted too many times by him and his annoying attitude. Bottom line: go for the ambience, but don't expect a fine gastronomic experience. Pros: Ambience, decor, wait staff Cons: Food, maitre d' more

Decent, but wouldn't go out of my way 1/12/2007

At 6:15 we were the only people in the place. The wait staff was nice, bread was good, and appies were good as well. My filet which was supposed to be medium, was well done, but I know better than to send it back... Not to mention by that time it was an old age home, so this 30 something couple decided to call it a night. We try new places often, and don?t mind paying 200+ for a good night at a restaurant. In this case it was not money well spent.. Middle of the road. Pros: Nice staff Cons: Food is middle of the road and not done to what you order. Over priced for what you get more

Not exactly Italian 1/2/2007

Scalini Fedeli was a very interesting restaurant. I seriously thought it was an Italian restaurant. It is actually a french with an italian influence. The maitre d was very obnoxious. We made reservations for four people, then called to add one more person and left a message. When we arrived he told us we should have called and spoken to a human, not left a message. He also said he did not have noise makers and hat for our extra person ( went on New Years Eve). The food was impressive. But as I said I thought i was italian cuisine. So I wanted a big bowl of pasta. I ended up eating seared tuna. Not at all something you would think of at an Italian restaurant. The food is good, the service is good. I do not think the money you pay is worth it. I will not return to this place. I have mixed feelings. Pros: Everything is tasty Cons: Not Italian more

Highly Rated by a Foodie 5/4/2006

I'm no food critic, but I'd like to think I have a tiny bit of experience under my belt having lived in NY for the last 11 years. That said, I thought Scalini Fedeli was one of the best dining experiences I've EVER had. From the complimentary chef app of a delicate butternut squash ravioli in a delicious truffle sauce to an amazing buttery and tender langostine entree to a dessert that I can't remember because of the fabulous Cakebread Cabernet we were drinking -- the whole evening was amazing. This is, by far, my favorite restaurant in NYC and I only wish it were more affordable so I could go more often! Pros: Amazing Food & Wine, Good Service Cons: Older crowd more

Fantastic 9/25/2005

I took my bf here for his birthday. This place really blew us away. It's gorgeous - yellow vaulted ceilings in a warm setting. Downstairs is a wine cellar which at the time was being used for a private party. The service was outstanding - attentive waiter w/a great knowledge of the food and wine. Right after we ordered a taste of what to come was given to us - a sample of mushroom ravioli. It was so impressive we could have asked for more. Each course that was given to us was well prepaired. We left stuffed. Truly a great experience - We'll be returning shortly. Pros: Great Food, Ambiance more

The way a restaurant should be. 5/23/2005

I had an excellent night there. Nothing bad to say, I could write on and on about the good things but I hate typing so I'll just say it was f'n awesome. more

Superb! 3/18/2004

This was one of the BEST restaurants I've ever been to. Not only was the food outstanding, but the little 'perks' were great. Complimentary stuff kept coming, and when the waiter saw me opening a gift, I received my dessert on a plate that had ""Happy Birthday"" written on it, with a candlevery nice touch, and attentive staff. The menu is Prix Fixe, so be prepared to spend at least $60 per person, but it is Well worth itsuperb food. Pros: Great atmosphere, Complimentary stuff, Attentive service more

Scalini Fedeli - AWESOME! 12/3/2003

All I can say is WOW! The food was amazing, the service was so attentive and personable, and how about that ambience! It's like you are transported to the Italian countryside, very romantic and filled with antiques. The ceiling is amazing! I would highly recommend this place to everyone for any occasion! Pros: Great Food, Great Service, Great Atmosphere Cons: none, none, none more

No Il Mulino.... 10/23/2003

Scalina Fedeli reminded me why service is so integral to fine dining. While the food was good (certainly no Il Mulino) the service was horrendous. Despite the fact that the space is large, they've overcrowded the floor with tables. My mother and I had our chairs bumped over a dozen times by hasty waiters... Our waiter was ever so helpful as he stood back and watched my sister and I physically move our table. As soon as my father lifted his pen from the check a chef appeared to usher us out. My entire family was horrified. Cons: overcrowded, rude service more

excellent 10/14/2003

Absolutely fantastic meal. The waiter showed us a little much of his personality, but, at the end of the day, every single thing we asked for was delivered... and then some. The food was fantastic. Definitely one of the top restaurants in the city. No questions about it. It's pricey, but you get what you pay for. Pros: food, wine more

Good, I Think! 7/22/2003

Went last Tuesday evening for my birthday with my wife and son . . . While the food was top-notch (very tasty pasta with sausage and risotto appetizers) along with braised ribs and veal entrees that were outstanding (my wife had the salmon which she said was the best she's ever had!), the place was very stuffy. The service was almost ""stealth-like"" (things came and went but the waitstaff, including the head waiter, had zippo personality!) So, the food was worth the visit (the desserts were outstanding too especially the chocolate cannollicini!) but, overall, the meal was too efficient and workman-like to make it a memorable experience. Pros: Excellent food! Cons: Service without a per more

The Best Italian 4/19/2003

Top notch from the entire night. Excellent service, better food & elegant ambience. I will recommend this place to everyone I know. One suggestion is to make a larger waiting room, it became a little tight. more

Don't Miss 3/9/2003

You definately do not want to miss Scalini. We were seated promptly, and the owner/chef came by to see how everything was. All of our dishes were exquisite and the service was impeccable. The atmosphere was low key but with great architecture and lighting. Definately come for a date or just a grat meal. more

superb 1/26/2003

superb food, superb service the owner chef walks around gets you extra things you want. had to wait 25 minutes for table . they paid for first round of drink which was nice. do not rush you. Pros: food, service, romantic more
< Previous 1 2 Next >

Menu for Scalini Fedeli




HOLIDAY DISCOUNT :
15% OFF all yearly plans
Use YEAR15 at checkout. Expires 12/31/2016

Editorial

  • The Scene
    Lemon-custard colored walls, arched ceilings, and plush carpeting set a serious tone at this former home to the legendary first iteration of Bouley. Tables are large and...

  • 6/2/2004 Provided by Citysearch

Additional information

  • Hours:

    Mon, 5:30-10pm; Tue-Thu, noon-2:30pm and 5:30-10pm; Fri, noon-2:30pm and 5:30-11pm; Sat, 5:30-11pm; Sun, closed
  • Payments:

    Visa, American Express, Diner's Club, Discover, Master Card
  • Neighborhoods:

    Downtown, Tribeca

Best Deals and Recommendations