JavaScript is not enabled.
Randy's Pizza - Durham, NC - Reviews page 1 - Judysbook
top 10

Randy's Pizza

1813 Martin Luther King Pkwy
Durham, NC 27707
(919) 490-6850
Incorrect info? Correct your listing


( 15 )
( 5 )
( 3 )
( 1 )
( 0 )


The food was so delicious. I got the lasagna, and the portion was huge. It also came with a salad and rolls, which were great. I only paid around $14 for all of it plus delivery, ...


Love thin-crust NY style pizza? I have visited all the Randy's pizza's in the area and I love the one on Miami Blvd in the RTP best of all. Their customer service is great. They ...

so legit. 4/28/2012

The food was so delicious. I got the lasagna, and the portion was huge. It also came with a salad and rolls, which were great. I only paid around $14 for all of it plus delivery, and it came quickly. I wish I knew about this place sooner. more

Very good but delivery is a risk 4/8/2012

4 stars because of delivery issues. Randy’s Pizza on Martin Luther makes excellent pizza. But I’ve had not so great experiences with delivery. One time when I opened the box the whole pizza was at one end. The box had obviously been turned on its side. On some occasions I got a great pizza in a fairly reasonable time. Once something happened so my order was very late and cold. I love their pizza but quit ordering takeout. Though the staff’s personality is a bit peculiar I highly recommend visiting Randy’s if you just want super good pizza. more

good taste, but questionable 1/23/2011

Generally taste food. Not at all health conscious and lately I was horrified to find a piece of mud in my salad. They exchanged if for a new salad, but my lunch time was ruined and they didn't offer to take it off the bill or a coupon. more

Best pizza in town 7/20/2009

By far the best pizza around. I grew up in Philadelphia, and this place makes pizza like I grew up with. They use real mozzarella, not the fake stuff the chain places use. Good pizza can be warmed and sold by the slice, and Randy fits the bill for that. And, the slices are huge! If you want a slice or two, go to Randy's. If you want a whole pie, go to Randy's. Their cheese steaks are very close to what I grew up with in PA. By far the best pizza that I've had while living in the South. Pros: Great pizza. large slices more

Excellent Pizza!!!!! 7/17/2009

These are the biggest slices in town, with the best taste. The cheese and sauce have excellent flavor. This is the only place I buy pizza, I love it. I'm spoiled by Brooklyn's Italians. Pros: Big and Yummy Cons: Location, Location, Location, not the best. more

Best Pizza....Bar NONE 7/12/2008

We tried Randy's Pizza for the first time in a long while last week, and had forgotten how outstanding the food is! Since the new ownership has taken over, the place is cleaner, the service terrific, and the new menu offerings are a welcome addition to the menu. \r We love the Classic Greek Pizza with the new Greek Salad. It was absolutely delicious. We went on a Friday evening, and the place was busy but not overly so. The service we got was the best in a long while. The staff was very accomodating, and we highly recommend Randy's Pizza for the huge slices, and the great service. They also deliver, too. Pros: Huge slices, fresh ingredients Cons: busy shopping center more

Good, but not sure I would go to this location again 6/19/2008

I went here with a couple friends, and the food was fine. The restrooms were less then acceptable, and the rest of the place was not very clean. The icing on the cake was when the employee put the pizza right in front of my baby, and he put his fingers in the cheese before I could stop him. A little common sense might be a good thing! \r \r I much prefer the Morrisville location, and I think I will stick to that on from now on. more

Don't expect quick delivery during lunch time.. 1/31/2007

We ordered food for lunch and was told we would have our food in 45 min to an hour. It actually took 1 hour and 35 min for us to get the food. When we called the young lady who answered the phone was very nasty. They may have great food but they offer poor customer service. Therefore they have lost me as a customer. more

Awesome NY style pizza 1/10/2007

Chewy, but crispy, flat crust; thick cheese; tangy sweet sauce - This is a really great NY style pizza joint that I'd never thought I'd find in NC. It's a great deal - 2 (big) slices with a topping and a drink for under 6 bucks. Service is speedy, toppings are classic and of a pretty good quality. (you need to go elsewhere for your artichoke hearts, sundried tomatoes, and pancetta). This is a solid pizza joint. Pros: Pizza, prices more

Love Randy's of RTP 1/6/2007

Love thin-crust NY style pizza? I have visited all the Randy's pizza's in the area and I love the one on Miami Blvd in the RTP best of all. Their customer service is great. They have a great staff that makes you feel at home. The pizza and sauce is by far superior to the other locations. The pizza is thin and the toppings are always cooked to perfection. For another tasty treat try their garlic knots, and ask for marinara on the side. It is deliciously ""spicy-sweet!"" You get great food at a great price- ~ 6 bucks for 2 large slices and I mean large and a drink. It is even worth the wait during the lunchtime rush. more

BEST Pizza Around.... No Kidding!!! 8/9/2006

I just love this place! I searched high and low for a decent pizza and sub place, since moving here from the north... I FINALLY found this GREAT place one night when I was going to the movies, and stumbled across it in the parking lot near Windsong Theatre.... I was thrilled to see another pizza place around here besides Dominoes and Papa Johns... UGGH!!! Talk about lousy pizza! \r \r Anyway, I went in and ordered 2 slices and a drink... I walked out of that place with a full tummy and a smile on my face... I had FINALLY had a piece of DELICIOUS pizza... Now I can call NC home :) \r \r Thank you Randy's for bringing us your NY Style pizza, with delicious sauce and cheeses... Talk about BIG slices, this place is the BALM!!!\r \r Everyone I bring here loves it too, and it's a place I always bring friends and company when someone says ""Any good pizza places around here?"". FINALLY I can say ""Yes, let's head over to Randy's""!\r \r PS... The subs are DELISH too, and I love the fact that they deliver! Believe me, they know where my house is! :D Pros: Best NY Style Pizza Around, Delicious Subs, Parking Lot Cons: Kind Of A Small Place more

Simply the BEST Pizza 12/11/2004

Nobody beats Randy's Pizza on Hope Valley Road!!! Their authentic NY Style pizza will remind anybody from up north what true NY Pizza still is! My entire neighborhood gets together every month and we all order from the Hope Valley Store. My family dines there nearly every week, and we would never consider another pizza restaurant. Since the new owner took over, the service has greatly improved, and that just adds a huge bonus to the great food. THEY EVEN DELIVER! If you live near the Southpoint Mall area, you better call Randy's at Hope Valley Road and check them WON'T be disappointed. Pros: great pizza, delivery, great value more

*Real* New York Pizza 2/5/2004

If you're looking for a real New York pizza place - both in food and in ambience - look no further. If you're looking for something trendy, then I'd suggest you look somewhere else. There are a lot of transplanted Yankees here in the Triangle (myself included), and this is a great place to get a taste of home. Pros: Excellent staff, New York Atmosphere, Food quality more

KM 9/5/2003

Randy's Pizza is the BEST pizza in the entire Triangle! Not only is it the best food the staff is wonderful and they get to know their cosutmers by name! I wouldn't eat pizza from anywhere else! Pros: Inexpensive, Casual, More than just pizza more

This Place is GREAT!! 8/29/2003

Being from Philly I'm a real Pizza lover and let me tell you that this place is awesome!!! more

Really the BEST! 8/27/2003

We've tried every pizza you can imagine in the Triangle and Randy's wins hands down. Randy's really should be voted the bestin town. Lilly's is good,don't get me wrong, but just try Randy's especially if you've spent any time up north (to get a REAL taste for pizza). I know the name ""Randy's"" doesnt sound like it would house the most authentic pizza in the Trainagle but it does!! Pros: pizza, pizza, pizza more

Randy's 7/24/2003

I have been going to Pizza joints run by Randy since 1992 and as a New Yorker this opinion counts. His is the best slice in the South, bottom line. more

Durham's/RTP's Finest Pizza 4/25/2003

This is thin crust heaven, plus fantastic calzones and stromboli's. I've eaten many times at the MLK location, but finally there is a place in RTP with good pizza (on Miami Blvd just south of I-40, on the left). Pizza is the perfect fast, cheap lunch, but until now, there was really no decent options near Nortel. And this place is excellent. The owners are right there every day, making sure the food is good and their customes are happy. Plus, they deliver. Pros: Best pizza, Great service, Owner operated Cons: I'll get fat, it's so good more

Good NY Style 12/1/2002

Randy's has some of the best Pizza in the Southwest Durham area, real NY style. If you're looking for real pizza instead of the ususal franchise crud, this is the place. They have great specials on Monday's. more

awesome 11/18/2002

The Randy's Pizza on Hope Valley Rd (same owner) is much better than the one on MLK, but both are pretty damn good. Closest to home (NY) pizza that I've had in this culture lacking town. more
< Previous 1 2 Next >

Menu for Randy's Pizza

15% OFF all yearly plans
Use YEAR15 at checkout. Expires 11/30/2016

Randy's Best New York Style Pizza, Subs and Salads in the Carolinas

Owner Message

  • Our specialty, at Randy's Pizza, is New York style pizza and subs. We offer pick up, dine in and delivery services. We gladly serve the finest New York style pizza outside of New York. Because all items are made to order, prep time is a few minutes longer,...


  • In Short
    Perfect for a casual dinner and a movie night in, or a treat after a long day at work. Sink into your couch and take a breather with a different kind of comfort food--pizza and...

  • 10/2/2006 Provided by Citysearch

Additional information

  • Hours:

    Mon-Fri 10:30am-10pm Sat 11am-10pm Sun 12pm-10pm
  • Payments:

    Discover, American Express, Visa, Master Card

Best Deals and Recommendations