This pizza is hands down the best I have had in Rochester. The ingredients are absolutely top quality, evident in every bite. The crust is crisp, yet chewy. The tomato sauce is flavorful and not too salty, like most pizza sauces. The cheese melts wonderfully and there is no grease floating on top of the pizza. The toppings are also fresh. Most pizzerias use canned mushrooms, for example. Pontillo's only uses fresh mushrooms.
I have also ordered the wings, which are tasty, yet small. I would stick with the pizza.
There are a few locations in Rochester and coupons are in the paper all the time.