I'm from Miami, where sushi, seafood, and dining in general are on an entirely different level. After moving to Tallahassee, I immediately tried every single sushi place recommended to me and learned that if Tally is the first place you've eaten sushi, then I probably won't trust your opinion. However, out of all the sushi places I've tried in this city, Osaka is the best. No scary pickled squid. The rolls, if you make good selections, they can be very, very appetizing. A nice feature this place has is that you can customize your own rolls if you want. Also, the entrees that aren't sushi are good too. The sashimi portion sizes are shamefully small (as they are everywhere in this city) and I have paid the same price for the same number of pieces only to have them half a big as they were before some nights.
Pros: good entrees & rolls, can customize, nice atmosphere
Cons: small sashimi portion, service can be slow, usually crowded