My wife and I had heard about Old Mill and I checked the reviews here on Citysearch. We decided to go when we read only raving reviews. When we arrived, we were immediately confused whether to go to the Grill or the Restaurant. I thought I had read about the restaurant, so we chose to go there.
Upon our arrival we were hurriedly sent to our seat. We DID have an excellent waitress, very good green beans and good catfish. After that, however, everything else was down hill. My country fried steak and mashed potatoes had very little taste. For the most part, the food tasted like cafeteria food. The atmosphere looked nice, but was loud and tacky.
Next time, maybe we'll try the grill.
Pros: Service was very good
Cons: Food quality was poor