Nocello

4.8
26 reviews
Write review
id: 27832964
marker

257 W 55th St
New York, NY 10019

marker
(212) 271-3022
Incorrect info? Correct your listing
Main categories:

Restaurants

Related categories:

Food & Dining

Reviews
( 19 )
( 7 )
( 0 )
( 0 )
( 0 )

Best

Was there last night with my family and we were all very happy with the service and food quality. I had the lamb and it was something really, really nice. Hostess was very charmin...

Worst

All reviews seem positive

nice and warm 2/4/2009

it's a great place to have a nice meal during this cold weather. it's really cozy in here. i also appreciate the new coat check girl, a nice touch! the risotto is also something special ! more
Reply | Report abuse |

Super 10/23/2008

nocello's a great northern italian restaurant. make sure to check it out, you will not be disappointed! Pros: Fresh Food, Courteous Staff, Great Ambience Cons: Need To Make Reservations Sometimes more
Reply | Report abuse |

Excellent Place 10/20/2008

My wife and I went for my birthday dinner and loved this place. The food was great, the service excellent and the place warm and inviting. Definitely look forward to going back more
Reply | Report abuse |

:) 10/13/2008

Lovely Northern Italian restaurant. Fresh food, decent prices and a welcoming atmosphere. I recommend making a reservation for the weekend otherwise everything is great. The staff is also a big A+ more
Reply | Report abuse |

Great! 10/13/2008

I went here with my husband recently and we really enjoyed it. he wrote a review before me and i decided to write one too because it was great. best northern italian place in manhattan. the vibe is great and the food is delicious. we're happy we found this place and will return soon! more
Reply | Report abuse |

Loved It 10/13/2008

I ran into this place by accident while strolling around Manhattan with my wife and i decided to check it out because i was starving. i tried the Vitello Del Borgo, it was great, i really enjoyed it and i also enjoyed the wine that the waiter picked out for me. it was a bit too crowded so i had to wait a bit for a table but other than that it was a pleasant experience! more
Reply | Report abuse |

movie night 10/9/2008

i went to the movies with my wife and on the way home we passed this place so we decided to go in and have a bite since there were a couple tables available. we both had cozze della casa. we enjoyed it but my wife said there was too much wine in her portion but other than that it was good. i also liked the wine selection. plus the service was courteous and prompt! more
Reply | Report abuse |

Valuable Place! 10/6/2008

What a treasure Nocello is. My office takes people here all the time and they are always delighted. Try anything! Never had a bad meal here. more
Reply | Report abuse |

Unpretentious 10/1/2008

My coworker took me to Nocello and since then I have been back four times. The wine selection is great and the atmosphere is so unpretentious. I highly recommend this place! more
Reply | Report abuse |

Northern Italian Delight 9/29/2008

We went here for the first time and I keep on going back. I love the atmosphere as well as the menu. It is a very european feel and tourists don't crowd it up. It is definitely a neighborhood crowd and I highly recommend it to my friends and friends from out of town for a spot that is relaxed and not swamped with out-of-towners. The food and service are exceptional and the owners are always walking around to say hello - which in NYC is very rare! more
Reply | Report abuse |

Make A Reservation 9/25/2008

Awesome place, the food is amazing and they show you how to pair any dish with wine and beer. Lots of people and it can take forever to get a table so make a reservation. Its popularity speaks for itself, can be expensive but is one of the best restaurants in NYC\r \r more
Reply | Report abuse |

interesting place 9/23/2008

I went in last week with my brother and had some food here. The service was just regular - not great, not bad. The waiter actually helped us pick out nice glass of wine. The food...Polo Carretiera was worth every penny! more
Reply | Report abuse |

A Midtown West find! 1/9/2008

The food is really amazing and the atmosphere is just right -- not too quiet, not too loud. \r I will absolutely return soon! more
Reply | Report abuse |

scallops 1/9/2008

my husband and i had dinner here recently. we both enjoyed the restaurant and especially the scallops. the wine selection was also good. we both recommend it to others, the atmosphere is delightful ! Pros: the atmosphere Cons: its recommended to make reservations more
Reply | Report abuse |

Best risotto in town 11/23/2007

The best risotto in town. I've had it with mussrooms or with mixed sea food so far. Otherwise this place has friendly and attentive staff and a nice selection of norhtern italian cuisine. It has no bar to sit at but you can get anything you want brought to the table. Nice for a quick lunch or a romantic dinner. Pros: parking across the street, great choice of dishes, friendly waiters more
Reply | Report abuse |

NOT A SECRET ANYMORE, BEST ITALIAN IN MIDTOWN 3/10/2007

Have been eating here for the last 7 years and did not want to write a review because I wanted to keep this place a secret. Unfortunatelly, it seems that the secret is out, judging by the long line of customers enduring the cold looking for a seat here during theatre time. Your best bet is to show up either on any Monday, or after your Broadway show. Food is out of this world, they have a great wine selection, athmosphere is enjoyable and very relaxed. Waiters have a great knowledge about what's going on in the kitchen but you're not going to see them too much during pre-show dinner. Try the house salad, the baby lamb chops and the wild berry tart to top your meal off. Great stuff at a reasonable price. Pros: food quality, value, wine selection more
Reply | Report abuse |

Good food, good service 1/11/2007

Went here with some friends, was pretty happy with the food. The menu is pretty varied, but I noticed that they use spinach in a lot of dishes. I'm not a huge fan of spinach, but found plenty to enjoy. Service is very good. Pros: Good food, good service Cons: Can be a bit pricey, but it's consistent with restaurants of a similar caliber. more
Reply | Report abuse |

Incredible service, authentic Italian 11/17/2006

From the moment you sit down and the maitre d begins describing teh day's specials, you realized you made a great choice. Every dish is described in suh detail that makes you realize what's happening inside the kitchen. And no matter what you choose, you realized it wasn't only a sales pitch. The food is amazing, gelatto is to die for, the atmosphere is very authentic and the service is superb. Please, don't leave without asking for a sip of Nocello to finish you meal. Pros: They're open until late, the location can't be topped and there's always a table. more
Reply | Report abuse |

Exceptional Food and Service 9/30/2006

I was there last night. Everything was delicious, especially lamb and risotto.My boyfriend had fettuccini in vodka sauce with lobster and it was absolutely perfect.The wait staff was attentive and nice. I would recommend it to anyone Pros: nice food and fast service, close to theaters more
Reply | Report abuse |

An amazing date restaurant! 7/8/2005

I have been going to Nocello for the last 8 years. Their food always impresses and their service is amazing. Penne Ala Vodka is unbelievable - best I have ever had! Wine selection and desserts are also notable. Pros: Atmosphere, Cost, Service more
Reply | Report abuse |
< Previous 1 2 Next >
Menu for Nocello


badge