Noah's has the greatest bagels and spreads in Seattle. I would highly recommend the strawberry spread, or the pumpkin pie spread when it's in season. I've never tried any of the sandwiches but they look good as well. They also have bagel dogs and egg mitts, which is a bagel with scrambled eggs on it. The bagels are a little pricey but I've always thought they're worth it.
Pros: Best bagels & spreads in Seattle
Cons: Pricey, not the cleanest place ever