JavaScript is not enabled.
New Yorker Marketplace & Deli - Atlanta, GA - Reviews page 1 - Judysbook

New Yorker Marketplace & Deli

Claim
marker
322 Pharr Rd NE
Atlanta, GA 30305
marker
(404) 240-0260
Incorrect info? Correct your listing

Photos

New Yorker Marketplace & Deli - Atlanta, GA
New Yorker Marketplace & Deli - Atlanta, GA
New Yorker Marketplace & Deli - Atlanta, GA
New Yorker Marketplace & Deli - Atlanta, GA

Reviews

( 9 )
( 3 )
( 1 )
( 0 )
( 1 )

Best

Great place to eat!!! I have been living here for 1 year after moving from CT. I really miss good old Jewish Deli after being spoiled with NY influenced deli in CT. I have fina...

Worst

We went there for the 1st time. My wife has been there before. It appeared dirty as we walked in. I asked to sample one of the meats and the waiter acted as if it was a major inco...

New Yorker Marketplace & Deli is Extremly Dirty 7/29/2010

We went there for the 1st time. My wife has been there before. It appeared dirty as we walked in. I asked to sample one of the meats and the waiter acted as if it was a major inconvenience. I ordered the turkey pastrami which was supposed to be 1/2 pound. \r \r We sat down in front of a fish case. The fish was on ice but the case was very warm. The salad case was even warmer, not to mention the glass was nasty looking. Our food came and my sandwich, I estimate, was about 1/4 pound. It didn't even cover the bread. \r \r As we ate. I looked for a health certificate. I could find none!! the straws are opened and in a open tray so everyone reaches in with their uncleaned hands and gets them, GROSS. no sanitation could be found. it also was about 90 degrees in the place. \r \r I will not go back and do not understand how anyone could reccommend this nasty place!!!! They used to get awards but I am sure the quality is GONE!\r Cons: very dirty doesn't give the amounts stated on menu more

Great food but DIRTY 1/20/2010

I hadn't been to the New Yorker in a few years and my husband and I decided to in for sandwiches. While our sandwiches were delicious, we were pretty disgusted by the looks of the place. The chairs were filthy and the tables and floor weren't much better. The case which holds the meet looked like it hadn't been cleaned in months. Makes me wonder- if the owners have no concern for what customers see in the front, what's the food prep area like? Hmmm.... Pros: Really good sandwiches Cons: Dirty! more

Home away from home!!!! 12/29/2009

Great place to eat!!! I have been living here for 1 year after moving from CT. I really miss good old Jewish Deli after being spoiled with NY influenced deli in CT. I have finally found my fix. My sister and I went today and it was fantastic. She had the turkey pastrami and I had the fresh mozz sandwich (sort of like a caprese). Delicious! I brought a turkey pastrami to my husband, who is from Brooklyn and he melted at our kitchen table. This place is wonderful, worth the money!! I will be back. If I could give it more stars, I would! Pros: Great food, Great Service Cons: I have to drive 30 mins to get there :( more

SIMPLY THE BEST 12/4/2009

Amazing little deli with fresh seafood. We live 2 hours away and will drive into town to buy our seafood from this shop. Every large party or gathering our guests rave at the taste of the food. I Believe me simply unbelievable! This place is a must try, but watch out you will get hooked! Pros: FRESH, FRESH, and Delicous!! Cons: if any parking more

Best Sandwich in Town 11/9/2007

This deli has the best sandwich in town - the Cubano. I've eaten every cuban sandwich you can find, including at the Havana Sandwich Shop, and the Cuban at The New Yorker Deli is not only the best Cuban in town, but the best sandwich in town. The pork is marinated in something so that it is juicy and ridiculously flavorful. In addition to the mustard, there's some other sauce that they put on the sandwich that makes it even richer and more delicious. I've literally had this sandwich 50 times, and every time it is perfectly the same. My mouth is writing just writing this. Pros: The sanwiches cannot be beat Cons: Seating is limited, but you can usually find somewhere to sit more

THE NAME SAYS IT ALL 11/6/2007

The New Yorker Marketplace and Delicatessen is the best way to visit the streets of Manhattan without being there! The sandwiches are fresh, wel prepared and plentiful. Take the time to look the menu over and get one of the specials. With some Zapps Chips and a Creme Soda a half sandwich is a GREAT LUNCH.... MY FAVORITE DELI SANDWICH SHOP. The New Yorker Marketplace and Delicatessen is a GREAT find. more

Fan frickin tastic every time! 1/4/2007

I've been going to this place every time I'm in the area for years and it is great every single time. Great service, fast, delicious, cheap, and it fills you up. Great soda selection and just great great great. Can't say enough about it. more

best sandwiches anywhere 10/15/2006

i discovered this place when i lived near it and ate lunch there every day nearly for months. i still like to go once or twice a week now that i live farther away. every sandwich i try is delicious!! Pros: great food, very friendly service Cons: none! more

SOOOO Yummy! 4/19/2005

After numerous recommendations from my NYC friends, I finally visited this deli. The sandwhiches were amazing...completely exceeding my expectations. This is the perfect casual, laid back sandwhich shop that you always wanted in your neighborhood. Definitely check it out! Pros: great food, fast service Cons: limited outdoor seati more

Best Sandwiches! 9/24/2002

I love this place for sandwiches so this makes Roz's Must Go for Atlanta list for that purpose. The food is fresh and fortunately so are the men! No, seriously, the food here is great! You gotta try it! - Roz more

This place is turning me into a Yankee! 8/24/2002

Do Chris and Carolyn ever take a vacation? Best prime cuts in town. Quick turnaround on telephone orders. Honest, practical answers to novice (asinine) questions re anything related to food and catering a party. Staff is unsung but diamonds in the rough. With them, C&C can take a couple of days off. Entrepreneurs who work hard and have customer service foremost in their minds. Obviously Yankee fans, but they don't rub it in. Pros: Service, Service, The Patrick Cons: Limited seating more

Don't Miss It! 8/17/2002

My husband and I eat lunch here every Saturday. Sometimes we eat breakfast too. Take away is also very good - we get their wonderful fresh fish for dinner often. Don't miss it! Pros: Great Food, Friendly Service Cons: Need more seating more

Gigantic sandwiches, friendly counter se 5/14/2002

These are some of the best sandwiches Ive had in Atlantatheyre absolutely huge and loaded with good stuff. Best bets: Turkey Rachel and the East Coast Roast. Call ahead and place your order or the wait can be long during busy times. Also, parking can be tough during lunchtime. Pros: quality, selection Cons: parking more

Best sandwich in town 5/13/2002

New Yorker Deli's Turkey Rachel sandwich is hands-down the best sandwich in town. The East Coast Roast isn't bad, either. more
< Previous 1 Next >
HOLIDAY DISCOUNT :
15% OFF all yearly plans
Use YEAR15 at checkout. Expires 12/31/2016

Editorial

  • The Scene
    This bright, lively deli features an appealing display case, Big Apple memorabilia and a small seating area. During the busy lunch hour, it's a hotbed of New York transplants...

  • 8/14/2003 Provided by Citysearch

Additional information

  • Hours:

    Mon - Sat, 9am - 5pm; Sun, closed
  • Payments:

    American Express, Visa, Master Card
  • Neighborhoods:

    Northside, Buckhead Village, Garden Hills

Best Deals and Recommendations