JavaScript is not enabled.
New York City Pizza - Hilton Head Island, SC - Reviews page 1 - Judysbook

New York City Pizza

Claim
marker
81 Pope Ave Ste 15B
Hilton Head Island, SC 29928
marker
(843) 842-2227
Incorrect info? Correct your listing

Photos

New York City Pizza - Hilton Head Island, SC
New York City Pizza - Hilton Head Island, SC
New York City Pizza - Hilton Head Island, SC
New York City Pizza - Hilton Head Island, SC
New York City Pizza - Hilton Head Island, SC

Reviews

( 6 )
( 1 )
( 0 )
( 0 )
( 7 )

Best

The renovations at the Pope avenue location are complete and the place is looking great. The wait staff are always friendly and the lunch specials are the best around.

Worst

We ordered a pizza that was made with a watery tomato sauce (Margarita Pizza) with four small pieces of basil, some globs of cheese and oil floating on top. It looked unappetizin...

The renovations at the Pope avenue 2/13/2012

The renovations at the Pope avenue location are complete and the place is looking great. The wait staff are always friendly and the lunch specials are the best around. more

Each visit to New York City Pizza is 1/18/2012

Each visit to New York City Pizza is such a pleasure. I am always greeted with a smile and Hello! My family loves the pizza and my little guy loves the spaghetti and meatballs. The atmosphere is great and those that work there truly seem to be happy with their job. I really enjoy when I can take time to sit and watch them make the pizza, talk with Amanda and Pat and just have a great time. Cheers to New York City Pizza! more

I grew up in a very Italian area of 1/15/2012

I grew up in a very Italian area of Brooklyn and know great pizza when it is served. At NYC Pizza the thin crust pizza is excellent. Their lunch specials are also excellent. I highly recommend the place, with one exception - the crust on their thick crust (i.e., Sicilian) pizza needs to be crispier. Bob more

Having been born and raised in the New 1/14/2012

Having been born and raised in the New York metropolitan area I honestly feel that this is the most authentic New York style pizza you will find in the Lowcountry. Their pastas and other entrees are also fantastic. The staff is courteous, helpful and very friendly. Highly recommended! more

great lunch special 2 slices 2 1/10/2012

great lunch special 2 slices 2 toppings salad and large beverage more

Rude Manager! 4/5/2011

We ordered a pizza that was made with a watery tomato sauce (Margarita Pizza) with four small pieces of basil, some globs of cheese and oil floating on top. It looked unappetizing and when I picked up a slice the sauce and toppings slid off. The waitress had the nerve to ask if we had ever ordered this kind of pizza before - like yea but it never looked like that! We returned the full pizza only to have the manager tell us that we still had to pay it! No apologizies for the awful pizza, just the manager telling us that he had to cover the cost of his products. He was completely rude and did not care one bit about customer satisfaction. Will never go there again and recommend that you don't go there either! more

worst lasagna EVER 4/10/2010

Holy hypertension! This was, hands Down , the worst lasagna EVER. It was so salty I had to send it back, the calamari was almost raw, the marinara sauce for the mozzarella sticks was so salty I felt like I coud drink a gallon of water. What a tremendous waste of time and money!!!! Pros: waitress was nice Cons: no soap in the restroom..makes me wonder more

BAIT GRADE TOPPINGS 11/14/2009

New York Attitude....bait my hook with better toppings? - ? - Pros: SPEEDY DELIVERY Cons: TOPPINGS SLOPPED TO ONE SIDE ... more

Awesome place 7/17/2009

I loove this place!!! Have the best food there! Pizzas are awesome! Go there at least once a week! My kids love new York city pizza!!!! more

The best food!!! 5/22/2009

I think NYC Pizza has THE best food in Hilton Head island! I loove that place! They have good atmosphere, awesome food, good workers! more

Horrible Service 1/2/2009

This has to be the WORST service I have experienced in quite some time. The manager was rude. The staff was totally uncaring and not helpful. It was overpriced for the food we received. Never again will we go there. Cons: Service, Service, Service more

clueless management 6/29/2008

I must have been next to the last reviewer because we sat for 90 minutes with 2 starving toddlers and neither the waiter nor the manager showed very much concern. We saw people walking out after not being served a drink for over 20 minutes past their arrival. And the restaurant wasn't even full so we couldn't understand what was going on. Terrible service- I would not waste a vacation evening at this establishment. more

Waited over an hour and twenty minutes for burnt pizza 6/29/2008

I just visited New York pizza, i was a regular customer, but after this experience, i don't think i'll be back. After waited for our server for over a half an hour, we finally contacted the manager, who acted clueless himself, and didn't even act like he cared. Our server finally came back to the table and told us that there was a mix up in the kitchen and our pizzas were being remade. This information should have been relayed to us when the mix up occured, instead of having us sit there for an hour before he came back to the table. The manager then came back to the table and told us 6 more minutes on the pizza, and that it was not the server's problem. I beg to differ because it was the server's reponsibility to acknowledge us, and keep us informed, which he failed to do. When we finally got the pizza, the bottom of the crust was torched, I mean really burnt. And after all that, they still added a 20% gratuity to our check. The server's name was Tim and we sat at table 28. The manager never came back to check on us either. This joint is unrecommended. Pros: The restuarant was clean Cons: Bad service, burnt pizza more

Eat elsewhere! Cold food! 11/11/2007

My husband & I ordered a large Stromboli with mushrooms, green peppers, onions, & spinich. After taking a bite of it, we noticed that it was cold inside. We sent it back to be put back in the oven. When they brought it back to our table, we took another bite out of it, but it was still cold inside. We told, who we assumed to be the manager/owner, about the cold Stromboli. He said that they were having trouble with the thermostat, but never offered to remedy the situation. After giving us a bill for the entire amount, we regrettably paid it, and left hungry. Cons: Cold food more
< Previous 1 Next >

Menu for New York City Pizza




HOLIDAY DISCOUNT :
15% OFF all yearly plans
Use YEAR15 at checkout. Expires 12/31/2016

Additional information

  • Hours:

    Mon. - Thu., Sun. 11am - 10pm;Fri. - Sat. 11am - 11pm
  • Payments:

    Discover, Master Card, Visa

Best Deals and Recommendations