My wife and I heard good things about this place and so far it has lived up to the hype. We ate there once before and had a personal sized pizza to sample it. I remembered that it wasn't bad, so we came back months later and ordered a 16 inch. It was great. We came around noon and the pie was ready in about 15 minutes. It tasted great when we got home, and hours later when we tried it cold. Nothing tastes better together than cold beer and cold pizza and very few can pull off the combination. Though I did enjoy it greatly, it's not the best I've ever had. This comes in 3rd. #1 is Giaordano's in Chicago, #2 is Little Italy in Arlington Tx(surprise), and #3 is Ned's Pizza. Never had NY Pizza so this personal list is subject to change. For Wisconsin, Yes this is the best pizza in the state so far.
Pros: Great Pzza, Fast preparation if you get there early
Cons: Not the best I've ever had...