GREAT service, the staff will remember you (they had our favorite table already reserved for my girlfriend and myself because they remembered us coming in the previous weeks!), wonderful food, and the best band I've ever heard in town. (Sportin' Paddy).
Try Mulligan's if you've got any desire to have a wonderful time out! (Friday and Saturday nights get LOUD and FUN, so if you're looking for a ""romantic"" evening like another reviewer, skip it and go to F. Scott's or something.
Pros: Food, Band, Service
Cons: Parking (downtown), pub-crawlers