Yeah, this theater is a little dirty at times, and the movies are old. If you look past that to the fact that you are seeing a movie on the big screen, with good surround sound, for $1.50, it just can't be beat. Well, unless you go to the one down in Greenwood, which shows much of the same stuff.
I have only had one bad experience at this theater, when watching War of the Worlds. It wasn't the movie's fault, like you would think, but the fact that there were a bunch of unattended kids running around the theater and yelling during the show. It wasn't more than 30 minutes into the movie before they were ejected, though.
Otherwise I have watched movies like Mr. and Mrs. Smith, Charlie and the Chocolate Factory, and that Traveling Pants movie with my wife and enjoyed every minute of it. Four stars for you.