JavaScript is not enabled.
Mitchell's Ocean Club - Columbus, OH - Reviews page 1 - Judysbook

Mitchell's Ocean Club

Claim
marker
4002 Easton Station
Columbus, OH 43219
marker
(614) 416-2582
Incorrect info? Correct your listing

Photos

Mitchell's Ocean Club - Columbus, OH
Mitchell's Ocean Club - Columbus, OH
Mitchell's Ocean Club - Columbus, OH
Mitchell's Ocean Club - Columbus, OH
Mitchell's Ocean Club - Columbus, OH
Mitchell's Ocean Club - Columbus, OH
Mitchell's Ocean Club - Columbus, OH
Mitchell's Ocean Club - Columbus, OH
Mitchell's Ocean Club - Columbus, OH
Mitchell's Ocean Club - Columbus, OH
Mitchell's Ocean Club - Columbus, OH
Mitchell's Ocean Club - Columbus, OH
Mitchell's Ocean Club - Columbus, OH
Mitchell's Ocean Club - Columbus, OH
Mitchell's Ocean Club - Columbus, OH

Reviews

( 7 )
( 5 )
( 3 )
( 2 )
( 1 )

Best

I stopped by to have a drink and a ppitizer.... wow.... great truffles!! I could not get over the atmosphere, and the kind waiting staff! I would recommend this resteraunt to anyo...

Worst

I made reservations a week in advance for an important dinner party with clients, I even went so far as to stop in 3 days beforehand and pick out the section we wanted seated in, ...

WOW good seafood 8/12/2009

I stopped by to have a drink and a ppitizer.... wow.... great truffles!! I could not get over the atmosphere, and the kind waiting staff! I would recommend this resteraunt to anyone who loves high end food. kudos to the Ocean Club Pros: best truffles in town Cons: wait to get in more

Best Restaurant Great Food Great Service 2/15/2009

If you want to go out for a special treat you need to try Mitchell's Ocean Club. From the warm wood decor to the walls of wine this place is very cool. I had the Filet Mignon and it was cooked perfectly with a side of cabernet jus that was obviously hand crafted and not made from a beef base. My wife had the Chilean Sea Bass which was cooked perfectly and melted in your mouth. Must try appetizers are Tuna Tartar with Avocado and Ponzu and the Jumbo shrimp in Tobasco Butter with cheesy bread. Side dishes are great too Jalapeno gratin-out of this world and the corn are a must. The wine list has more than enough selections (maybe 200) and if you can't find a wine ask for the captains list, some real gems! I don't have enough room to write how great the service was from the time we entered to the time we left. I can tell you we mentioned to the server that we had a baby sitter and they gave us a dessert to give to her--BLOWN AWAY!! If you want a $50.00 meal go to Brio or PF Changs if you want to live like a king for a night visit Mitchell's Ocean Club. I have been to many restaurants in many states and this is by far one of the best. Pros: Service, Food, Decor, Cleanliness, Perfection Cons: Can be loud but we like action more

Perfect for a Special Occasion 10/9/2007

My boyfriend and I came here for our one-year anniversary, and I couldn't have asked for a better place to celebrate. We went on a Saturday night at 6:30 and stayed until 9:30---there was no rush to hurry out of the restaurant at all. The food was fantastic. I had the pineapple-infused-vodka martini with dry ice, which added an incredible effect! We had the calamari to start (good, but kind of a lot for two people because the taste wears on you after a bit), then the caesar salad and beefsteak tomato salad, both of which were wonderful. I had the king crab legs, which is 1 lb. and they are really huge, and my boyfriend had the filet, Oscar-style, which was excellent. We had asparagus and a twice baked potato on the side, both of which were perfectly done...and we had to take half of the sides home because we were so stuffed! We split the pound cake dessert, which is more like an ice cream cake with meringue ""frosting"" and Graeters ice cream...yum. It was expensive (!), about $160 including tip for both of us, but well worth it for a special night if you want to go all out. And our service was impeccable. The server chatted with us just enough to be friendly and make us feel at home, but kept the perfect amount of distance, too. I can't imagine a better evening. Pros: Service, Food, Ambiance, Romantic, Great Special-Occasion Cons: Price can add up if you get all the trimmings more

Better than the previous 8/24/2007

The new patio is great, as is the bar. The dining room can be a bit difficult to navigate on a busy night, most often because of the few access points waitstaff have. The food is generally good, the Ahi Tuna and Avocado appetizer is out of this world. Try the Chef's Selections, they are portioned appropriately and though sometimes over-flavored or overwhelmed by an ingredient, are most often good. Pros: Location, good looking hostesses more

Overrated & Overpriced 8/23/2007

After dining at several of Cameron Mitchell's restaurants around the city, I was prepared for great atmosphere, excellent tasting food, sizeable portions and reasonable prices at the Ocean Club. I did find that the food was prepared very well with many wonderful flavors, however, my overall experience left me unsatisfied. My wife and I are not frequent diners at such up-scale restaurants, and when we do decide to splurge on a meal, we like to feel our money was well spent. The $60 we spent on two very small crab cakes and four scallops did not generate such a feeling. Furthermore, my ""crab"" salad only included one very tiny piece of crab (maybe 3/4"" square). I realize gourmet food is synonymous with small portions, but these portions were laughable in comparison to those plated at Cameron's other establishments. Second, my glass of merlot, again small, was not properly poured. I realize that sediment does, at times, form in a stored bottle of wine, but the bartender should be trained well enough to know how to keep that sediment in the bottle rather than just dumping it all into a customer's glass. Last, when booking my reservation, I was told that the restaurant?s dress code was business casual or formal. However, the diners we encountered wore denim summer wear with adolescent children in tow. Hardly the upscale atmosphere my wife and I expected while celebrating a special occasion. I do wish to thank our server for the free dessert in honor of my wife's birthday. However, that may be the only pleasant memory we will have of the Ocean Club. In total, we spent around $100 for dinner, and next time we visit Easton, I think we'll give P.F. Chang's the opportunity to satisfy our appetites. Sorry. Pros: great tasting food Cons: extraordinarily tiny portions, below average bar staff, need to enforce dress code more

should have kept it the way it was 8/14/2007

I've dined at Ocean Club several times, both the ""original"" Ocean Club and the now remodeled, new concept. The food is still delicious, and the service excellent, but I don't care for the Steakhouse feel and the A la Carte menu items. I concur with some of the other people who commented on the excessive noise of the piano. more

Any time 11/20/2006

You will not believe that but I had the best chicken in my life in Ocean Club!!! Amish chicken is just like heaven!!! My fiances fish was also out of this world!!!! more

steakhouse style menu 9/7/2006

Great job on the new decor, but.....could do without dry ice martinis - too much of a gimmick. Pros: decor and patio Cons: LOUD! gimmicky bar meny more

The Swordfish is the best! 6/26/2006

Their Swordfish is the best! Grilled with veggies on top of creamy rice... yummy! The price is comprehensive too. I like to sit besides the window and people watching. Service? Couldn't be better. more

Terrible! 6/28/2005

Both visits...add poor service with an overly crowded resturant, and you get a noisy and hot visit. Mix that with portions small enough to feed a cat, and you get a bad dinning experience. The food (portion size aside) isnt even that good. To add insult to injury, wait untill you get the bill! The Ocean Club is over rated. If you want to be a trend-setter, and show off your nice watch and suit, this is the place for you. But if you want a nice meal, go somewhere else...anywhere else. Pros: there arent any Cons: everything more

Poor service 1/14/2005

This was my first time at the restaurant. I made reservations and they seated us next to the bar in a smoking area. The service was quite poor. The food attempted to make up for it. Great swordfish, average surf'n'turf. Great wine for the price. I would choose other restaurants for the money. Pros: Good food, Ambiance more

Great food & location...Poor Service 10/4/2004

Ocean Club makes a great attempt to fit into the Easton setting and, although boasts good food, falls short on ambience and service. With giant mirror fish on the walls and endless undulating waves, the ornate decorations offer a more gaudy appeal, rather than what it was intended for. The dishes are well-prepared, which is to be expected at a Mitchell joint, and is infused with asian seasonings and preparations. Unfortunately, the obnoxious bartenders and sub-par service makes Ocean Club a not-so-worthwhile experience. Pros: Good Food, Great location, Fairly priced Cons: , Rude bar staff more

delicious! 6/7/2004

The food was beyond compare, but it is a bit expensive. Not much under $20 a plate. Overall I would recommend it. Pros: excellent food Cons: , average service more

My favorite restaurant 4/18/2003

Ocean Club is my favorite restaurant in columbus. I drive 40 minutes just to eat there. The food is fantastic and the ambiance even better Pros: Inexpensive, friendly Cons: parking more

Best restaurant in the city!! 9/11/2002

My wife and I went to the Ocean Club for our second wedding anniversary and it was beyond what we expected. It was our first time dining at the Ocean Club and it was recommended by some friends but we couldn't have imagined that it was this fantastic. Our server catered to our every need and the food was absolutely wonderful. I had the scallops and my wife had the salmon both of which where recomendations by our server. The mushroom sauce with my scallops was perfect and my wife liked her salmon so much she wouldn't even let me have a bite!! Everything was so wonderful, I could say more but don't have enough room. We plan on coming back to the Ocean Club way before our next anniversary and highly recommend it to our friends as the best restaurant in the city. Pros: Wonderful food, Service, Beautiful Restaurant Cons: Parking more

Disappointed 8/14/2002

I made reservations a week in advance for an important dinner party with clients, I even went so far as to stop in 3 days beforehand and pick out the section we wanted seated in, the table, and the view we wanted. When we arrived at the restaurant the table was not ready and when they went to seat us, they had disregarded the arrangement we had previously made. After we waited for an additional 10 minutes we were finally seated in the back room, where we had to yell across the table to one another. I guess next time I will have to set the table up myself... Pros: Wonderful Waitress, Good Wine, Delicious Ravioli Cons: Poor Management, Immature Staff more

Just right 7/16/2002

From beginning to end the whole experience was great, right down to the blue cheese-stuffed olives in the wife's martini. Food presentation was wonderful, service was excellent. I can't think of a single reason why I wouldn't be back. Noise level was a little high, but that's to be expected on a Friday night. more

Anniversary 2002 7/8/2002

Total bill a little over $50.00 for 2 people. We had beer and iced tea/split a house salad/Grilled Swordfish w/mashed potatos and carrots/Ginger crusted salmon w/sticky rice and broccoli. Portions were very large (that's why we split a salad). I thought the swordfish was just a bit overcooked alond with the mashed potatos being a bit dry. The salmon was perfect. Got a free desert because of our anniversary. Service was excellent. Not a place for small children. Pros: portions, service, free parking more
< Previous 1 Next >

Menu for Mitchell's Ocean Club




HOLIDAY DISCOUNT :
15% OFF all yearly plans
Use YEAR15 at checkout. Expires 12/31/2016

Editorial

  • The Scene
    Looking like Beverly Hills minus the palm trees, the Ocean Club nests on the second level of Easton Town Center, overlooking the mall's faux streetscape.

    The...

  • 8/18/2003 Provided by Citysearch

Additional information

  • Hours:

    Mon. - Thu. 4pm - 10pm;Fri. - Sat. 5pm - 11pm;Sun. 4pm - 9pm
  • Payments:

    American Express, Discover, Cash, Visa, Master Card
  • Neighborhoods:

    Easton, Northeast Columbus

Best Deals and Recommendations