My husband and I love going here on romantic dates. The atmosphere really does remind us of a fantastic vacation we had in Tuscany years ago.
The tables are close together - so if you don't like that, you may feel uncomfortable. Just know, this is what all the little restaurants and cafes are like in Italy!
The food is great! We love the appetizers!! The chef has a traditional menu, but makes them different than you would expect. It's good!!
The main con would be price and business. This is a tinge spendy (but worth it). You also need to make a reservation -- particularly during the school year since it is a hot date place right near PLU.