At the beginning, this place is not very impressive (as far as the entrance is concerned). The Customer Service is not something to brag about either (they were just OK but not rude in any way, just slow). \r
However, the food in this place (as far as freshness and variety) beats 99% of the seafood specialty restaurants in City Island and in most places in New York.\r
The prices cannot be beaten (not a cheap hole-in-the-wall restaurant) and some of the waitresses are top notch eye candy. \r
Best of all they have an interesting ambiance (like dancing and Karaoke-Depending on weeknight) and clear floors with views to Fish Tanks (like those on glass-bottom boats and cruises).
Pros: Excellent Variety, Fresh Seafood, Great Prices
Cons: Very Slow Service once the food is on the table. Seems like they forget that they need to come back every 5 minutes or so.