They make flavors you never thought of, that once you try you wonder how you couldn't have. Everything is made at the shop and is locally owned. The owner is a community supporter, and frequently donates for local causes. They have 20+ flavors on hand all the time. There are board games to play, but it does get crowded with families and college students. They focus on organic, and often serve a hot organic chillie or somthing else hearty if you aren't in the mood for ice cream.
Pros: unique flavors, locally owned, wide selection
Cons: small space