My wife and I were married on Lopez and several of our guests stayed here and raved. They have 4 or 5 private cabins for rent, all recently built and with nice amenities like fireplaces, mini-kitchens with refrigerators, etc. Not super-fancy, but private, cozy and well-located (on the north end of the island, near the ferry landing and Lopez Village).
Pretty sure they're available year-round, but call ahead to make sure.
more