I had dinner at La Maganette once. Their appetizers and main dishes were really excellent - I dined with 5 people and everyone loved it. The waiter has been there for 30 years, he was a little weird, but very nice.
The place is nicely decorated, although it's borderline tacky. There are many tables with umbrellas outside, and it's usually packed during lunch.
There were two things I disliked about this restaurant. First, there were so many elderly people there that I felt I was eating in some nursing home. It was a bit depressing. Second, the desserts were absolutely disgusting, the most awful I've ever had at a restaurant. Their tiramisu was served frozen. The cheescake was old and room temperature. Even the waiter agreed that their dessert is nasty, and that the chef is clueless when it comes to dessert.
Pros: Good Main Dishes
Cons: Disgusting desserts, Too many elderly