Overall, a disappointment, but with a couple of important exceptions (please read entire review):
The service is good and atmosphere quaintly quiet and intimate, the preparation and (most) ingredients are of high quality, that's the good news.
If you're looking for a quiet place to meet and talk, you could do much worse.
The cuisine, however, is something of a let-down.
To my tastes, Mexican food evokes a certain amount of flavor and texture and zest.
I'm not talking spicy-hot here, in fact I'm a bit of a wimp when it comes to food that bites back and clears my sinuses.
I first dined here last November, meeting with my half-brother while he was in town.
I ordered a seafood enchilada, and might as well have been handed a slab of microwaved tofu.
The shrimp were those tiny bay shrimp, not what I'd expect to find inside a tortilla, and the crab mushy and flavorless, and if any seasonings were used, I couldn't taste them. I'd have done better with imitation crab at three bucks a pound at Ralphs, at least that stuff has texture. The corn tortilla was apparently steamed, no cheese or sauce toppings.
Because I was dining with family, I didn't raise any fuss at the time because I was dining with family, but several months later I came across a show called ""Kitchen Nightmares"" and that got me thinking. I decided to post a review, but decided I should contact management to see what went wrong.
Management invited me to come back in and try a 'replacement' meal of equal value. Turns out he is never there when he's supposed to be, so I was never able to talk with him in detail about the experience, and it wasn't clear whether he even understood the problem. But when I showed up and he wasn't there, a friendly, very-professional waitress who spoke and understood pretty fluent English eventually showed up and greeted me.
I described the flavorless, disappointing experience, she confirmed that it had been prepared and served correctly. So I tried something else.
The hard-shell beef taco and beef enchilada proved to be equally bland. The rice and refried beans were standard fare, chips came with salsa that was too hot for me to handle.
The waitress said their customers preferred the meals bland, so if you want bland, mid-priced mexican food in a pleasant atmosphere...
And that is the other exception.
The reason I was dining here with my half-brother, the reason he was in town, is that he has Crohn's disease, and just up the street is Good Samaritan Hospital, which has a clinic specializing in digestive disorders, and whose own kitchen is much more disappointing than this place can ever be.
They don't advertise it, but their meal menu apparently caters to digestive disorders with low tolerance for seasoning.
And, while the flavor is missing, the quality doesn't appear to be. Setting aside the conundrum of serving chips with dangerously-hot salsa, it's probably a pretty good dining experience for connisseurs of bland food (blandies?)
They still need to use bigger shrimp.
Pros: quiet, intimate atmosphere
Cons: flavorless cuisine
more