JavaScript is not enabled.
Johnny's New York Style Pizza - Atlanta, GA - Reviews page 1 - Judysbook

Johnny's New York Style Pizza

Claim
marker
834 Virginia Ave
Atlanta, GA 30354
marker
(404) 766-3727
Incorrect info? Correct your listing

Reviews

( 7 )
( 3 )
( 1 )
( 2 )
( 3 )

Best

A very friendly fast pace restaurant, with great food and drinks. The PIZZA (anyway you want it) is great, but the SUBS are better. The DRINKS come in large plastic cups, the BEER...

Worst

Only good thing to get here is a sandwich. (The sandwiches stand with any in the area). Hot or cold will satisfy your appetite. Because of the extreme volume of business at thi...

Editorial review from Citysearch 2/9/2013

TERRIBLE food and lackluster service. Seemed like the employee morale wasn't great, but the food... :-(( !! The lemon pepper wings were served in a bowl without so much as a sprig of parsley, and they were wet/soggy, and over salted, and had no hint of lemon except what I squeezed on. Maybe I was overambitious ordering eggplant parmesan, but it was just a big mushy mess of breadcrumbs and (a fairly tasty) sauce with some eggplant hidden underneath with cheese on top. Even the little salads tasted like the ones you get pre-made at the grocery store. Beer selection was mediocre, but at least they were cold and the bread was good. C'mon guys - put a little love in the food at least for $27!!! more

Johnnys worst service and the owner is rude 11/8/2010

We have visited there off and on due to location, food always average, restaurant always unkept and worn out. more

worst crap i ever ate!!!!!!! 2/21/2010

i stopped in to jonhnny's to grab something to eat for my lunchj break. i get to work ready to dig into my sub and it's completly wrong and the size of a mcdonald's kid's menu sandwich when i paid over $10 bucks for it!!!! then when i call to get it replaced the ""management"" was EXTREMELY rude and would not refund my order!!!! i will never eat here again!!!!! Pros: close 2 my job Cons: my order was completly wrong and they were jerks!!!!!!!!!! more

Beat Pizza anywhere 6/12/2007

Johnny's New York style pizza is the best... try atlanta's best pizza......... ...... ......... ......... more

Best average pizza in area 2/24/2003

Jonny's has picked up where Mellow Mushroom has flavor and quality has left off. It is my favorite average pizza joint in the city. more

earlelmoeidecker 1/8/2003

A very friendly fast pace restaurant, with great food and drinks. The PIZZA (anyway you want it) is great, but the SUBS are better. The DRINKS come in large plastic cups, the BEER in cold bottles or cold mugs. The PEOPLE that work there make it happen. Try the Oreo Cheese Cake for DESSERT. more

LOVE this pizza 1/2/2003

Johnny's is the best! They totally rock. The white pizza is awesome and where else can you get good spinach, feta cheese, artichoke hearts and sundried tomatoes on a pizza. Certainly not at any of the national chains! Pros: Many locations, friendly, delivery Cons: salads could use work more

The BOMB Pizza :) 1/2/2003

If you are craving some really good HOT TASTING Pizza...this is where you need to go :) Not only is there food is off the chain...but there service is quick and friendly. Pros: Food, Service more

Not really pizza 12/16/2002

Only good thing to get here is a sandwich. (The sandwiches stand with any in the area). Hot or cold will satisfy your appetite. Because of the extreme volume of business at this location, most foods are prepared ahead of time. What they call a calazone is pre-cooked with only cheese. When you order they slice it open insert additional ingredients and reheat. Pizza by the slice works the same way. Arrive early Pros: sandwiches, salads Cons: calazones & pizza more

If you like burned crust 12/6/2002

Every single time I have gotten food at Johnny's it is burned on the bottom. I won't be going back. Cons: Burned crust more

yummy pizza 11/27/2002

when i first visited this restuarant, i was amazed at the taste of the pizza taste it was almost like being back in new york, very good.... Pros: very tasty, just like back home, also, lol more

Jonny's is the best 11/27/2002

The food here is very good.People are friendly,service is very good.But, overall the food is excellent!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Pros: food, very clean, famliy place Cons: none, none, none more

not to be sappy, but this pizza's crappy 11/10/2002

we are from the northeast where we are quite spoiled when it comes to pizza, and this doesn't even compare to gas station pizza from the north. this is terrible pizza and is in no way new york style. i don't recomend this pizza at all, and it's not even in the same class with mellow mushroom which is mediocre in itself. the only good thing i can say about jonny's is that they do have garlic shakers on the tables, where everywhere else in town you have to beg for garlic. more

You have got to be kidding! 10/31/2002

I have both lived in and travelled around most of the U.S. at one point or another. Honestly, I found Johnny's to be below Chuck E. Cheeses. It is by far the greasiest, grossest and most inedible pizza anywhere. It's amazing that anyone can swallow the garbage they make. Pros: There aren't any more

simply the best 10/25/2002

I've eaten at Johnny's for years, this place has the best pizza I have ever eaten. The best thing is they have alot of stores in Atlanta and elsewhere, that means I can get the best pizza anytime anywhere Pros: Great food, great prices, cold beer Cons: closes too early more

For the love of pizza 8/13/2002

Generous ingredients on the pizzas, great sandwiches....and the service was excellent. more

ruins my diet every time! 8/1/2002

I love the old fashioned cheese pizza here. The crust is perrrfect and the sauce is zesty and the chesse is greasy. You cant go wrong. I frequent the one on /elizabeth street. DELICIOUS! They however wont deliver to my neighborhood. Go figure. more

yummy 7/31/2002

The crust is thin and just enough crispy. The ingredients are plentiful. They will even make a pizza with something different on each quarter (great for your kids). The sauce has a great flavor. Very family friendly restaurant. Pros: comes by the slice, great crustq, great sauce Cons: cost, not a lost of seating more
< Previous 1 Next >

Menu for Johnny's New York Style Pizza




CYBERWEEK:
50% OFF all yearly plans
Use CYBERWEEK at checkout. Expires 12/4/2016

Additional information

  • Payments:

    Master Card, Visa, American Express, Discover

Best Deals and Recommendations