JavaScript is not enabled.
Iron Forge Inn - Bellvale, NY - Reviews page 1 - Judysbook

Iron Forge Inn

38 Iron Forge Rd
Bellvale, NY 10912
(845) 986-3411
Incorrect info? Correct your listing

Main categories:

Restaurants , American Restaurants

Related categories:

Food & Dining


( 0 )
( 2 )
( 1 )
( 0 )
( 0 )


i think the menue is well put together yet the prices are rather steep. its verry comfortable however the staph can come off alittle prude or to. how do you say... high on there ...


All reviews seem positive

country setting with eligance 2/20/2008

i think the menue is well put together yet the prices are rather steep. its verry comfortable however the staph can come off alittle prude or to. how do you say... high on there horse? it is good food and a nice setting but i think it needs to be toned down a bit. i didnt see any of the wait staph driving a bentley yet they try to put off that kind of atitude. other than that i think it is a wunderful restorante in the warwick area. 40 min north of the city {not upstate ny} is a nice get away especialy after a day in the vineyards. or a hike olong the apilachian trail.. but be prepared to put your best dress on. also a nice place for a date.\r Pros: good food, nice fire place. Cons: high prices and hard to find. more

A country restaurant worth trying.... 12/26/2007

I feel the other review is slightly unfair. I work in Manhattan, but also happen to live upstate. You can't fairly compare restaurants in a rural area against those in the city. The bottom line is if you would like to experience a calm break from the norm w/very nice unique food & wonderful genuine service- then go to the Iron Forge Inn.\r Located about an hour+ from NYC, you'll find a beautiful scenic mountainous area w/lakes, farms, wildflowers & country roads. Down a quiet road you'll find the Iron Forge Inn which is really an old landmark house turned restaurant/bar. It has charming wood built ins, working wood burning fireplaces & antique details- down to the original & not perfectly straight hardwood floor. In nice weather, you can eat out in the private gazebo & enjoy great views.\r I went for my anniversary. They started us w/a complimentary seasonal hordevour the chef created using local ingredients. The menu is actually sophistaicated for what you would expect to find upstate (See it online on their website). The courses are served well timed & tempered. Several staff Including the Owner check on you throughout your meal to be sure you have everything you need. No need to wait for that ""1 waiter."" The staff are genuinely kind & professional & made the expereince great (& I'm not easily impressed being a manager in a 5 star establishment). The food was made w/creative ingredient combinations. I was expecting it to be served casually, but it was actually fancifully presented. Some of it was great, some good, but nothing ""bad."" I'll definately go back. The old fashioned charm brought me back to a simpler time & made me relax & forget my modern woes. At the same time it was not so simple that I felt gypped. I was pleased w/the fine service & impressed by the chefs choices in the menu. The bill was fair; not too high, not too low. We left a big tip because it was well deserved. JTB Pros: Warm environment, great staff, creative menu Cons: A little hard to find if you dont live local or have GPS! more

cute country inn 10/2/2006

My husband and I went here the past weekend after a nice drive into NY state. The place is ""cute"", serivce is great, but, we didn't enjoy the menu. We think the chef was trying to be too fancy with those dishes, and the menu was too small for us. The veggies seemed to be ""soaked"" in something,they were too ""wet."" I think it is a nice place to try one time if your in the area. We wouldn't go again. Pros: very pretty inside Cons: not such a great menu, too expensive, not worth the high price more
< Previous 1 Next >

Menu for Iron Forge Inn

15% OFF all yearly plans
Use YEAR15 at checkout. Expires 11/30/2016

Additional information

  • Hours:

    Thurs-Fri 6-11 pm, Sat 5-11 pm, Sun 11 am-1:30 pm, 3-10 pm

Best Deals and Recommendations