When I was planning my wedding two years ago, I booked my reception at the Autumn Ridge Golf Club. Their official caterer was Goeglein's, so I contacted them and visited their place on Maysville Road. Goeglein's has extensive menus to choose from. I find their choices to be very affordable, and the food very well prepared.
Years later, the Lutheran Foundation had their meeting at the premises and Goeglein's has really delivered! Massive spread, plus that chocolate fountain!
I have heard from various people who tried other caterers and they wished they had Goeglein's cater their events.