My father is from Archbald and we have frequented Old Forge since we were children, always returning to the same place...this one makes the best white pizza (white with broccoli is a particular favorite of mine). If you like pizza, go to Old Forge. There is absolutely nothing like it...and order a tray, not a pie!
Pros: white pizza, white broccoli pizza, old forge, location, history, service
Cons: getting more expensive