JavaScript is not enabled.
Georgia's Bake Shop - New York, NY - Reviews page 1 - Judysbook

Georgia's Bake Shop

Claim
marker
2418 Broadway, New York, NY 10024 (at @ corner 89th Street)
New York, NY 10024
marker
(212) 362-2000
Incorrect info? Correct your listing

Main categories:

Restaurants , Mexican Restaurants , Brunch

Related categories:

Food & Dining

Photos

Georgia's Bake Shop - New York, NY
Georgia's Bake Shop - New York, NY
Georgia's Bake Shop - New York, NY
Georgia's Bake Shop - New York, NY

Reviews

( 10 )
( 6 )
( 0 )
( 2 )
( 6 )

Best

I come here all the time and enjoy the pastries while sitting outside or inside depending on the weather. The inside is like a southern French country bakery. Very cute and cozy...

Worst

Although the flavors were good I had a very specific situation of finding a considerably big and pointy stick in my Canelloni dish which according to the cheff happens to be a Ros...

Best and "prettiest" cupcakes in NYC 6/17/2011

I come here all the time and enjoy the pastries while sitting outside or inside depending on the weather. The inside is like a southern French country bakery. Very cute and cozy! The pastries are my favorite - especially the "new" cupcakes. Almost too pretty to eat. BUT, do eat them they taste as good as they look - yummy and scrumptious. The wait staff is friendly and helpful - the place is clean - and they also serve REAL FOOD. Meaning breakfast, lunch and dinner. Georgia's has a fantastic menu. BTW, this is a great dating place too - very romantic!!! more

Best and ""prettiest"" cupcakes in NYC 6/17/2011

I come here all the time and enjoy the pastries while sitting outside or inside depending on the weather. The inside is like a southern French country bakery. Very cute and cozy! The pastries are my favorite - especially the ""new"" cupcakes. Almost too pretty to eat. BUT, do eat them they taste as good as they look - yummy and scrumptious. The wait staff is friendly and helpful - the place is clean - and they also serve REAL FOOD. Meaning breakfast, lunch and dinner. Georgia's has a fantastic menu. BTW, this is a great dating place too - very romantic!!! more

Skip Starbucks and definitely go here instead 9/29/2010

Go there, get a cappuccino, try one of their pastries, and you will automatically be off to a great morning. Try the spaghetti carbonera and the steak and eggs entree too--delicious! more

Skip Starbucks and definitely go here instead 9/29/2010

Go there, get a cappuccino, try one of their pastries, and you will automatically be off to a great morning. Try the spaghetti carbonera and the steak and eggs entree too--delicious! more

Love it here 9/14/2010

Cozy, nice people, good atmosphere. Coming here on weekends is a pleasure each time. We like the eggs benedict, and they have some good dinner here too. The charred octopus was really good, and all of the salads we usually get (i forget the names) are unique and delicious more

Love it here 9/14/2010

Cozy, nice people, good atmosphere. Coming here on weekends is a pleasure each time. We like the eggs benedict, and they have some good dinner here too. The charred octopus was really good, and all of the salads we usually get (i forget the names) are unique and delicious more

My morning fix 8/3/2010

Perfect place to start your morning off the right way. SO much better then going to starbucks or the other generic cafe's in the area. This place has full greatest, a very large variety of hot morning beverages, and the staff is always very friendly and puts a smile on my face! more

My morning fix 8/3/2010

Perfect place to start your morning off the right way. SO much better then going to starbucks or the other generic cafe's in the area. This place has full greatest, a very large variety of hot morning beverages, and the staff is always very friendly and puts a smile on my face! more

Great place, good breakfast 7/14/2010

Come here all the time to get my morning coffee and either a sandwich or one of their eggs benedicts. Stuff is delicious and makes my morning. They have some really great baked goods, and they are pretty quick in the morning even when its crowded! Pros: Great eggs and baked goods more

Great place, good breakfast 7/14/2010

Come here all the time to get my morning coffee and either a sandwich or one of their eggs benedicts. Stuff is delicious and makes my morning. They have some really great baked goods, and they are pretty quick in the morning even when its crowded! Pros: Great eggs and baked goods more

Morning treat! 6/17/2010

I visit Georgia's almost every morning. They have a delicious cappucino that is large, creamy, and the definitely the best one in this neighborhood. The eggs benedict is really fabulous, and for lunch, they have this dish called the spring penne paste--comes with fresh mozzarella, olive oil, some cherry tomatoes, and other fresh ingredients. It's really the perfect place to visit before work, they have a warm and friendly environment, a great set of baked goods, and they are efficient for the most part. This place also isn't commercialized as Starbucks has become, and they don't let you just hang out at a table for hours without buying anything. Pros: Friendly service, quick in the morning, delicious breakfast Cons: A bit crowded at times, sometimes difficult to get a waiter more

Morning treat! 6/17/2010

I visit Georgia's almost every morning. They have a delicious cappucino that is large, creamy, and the definitely the best one in this neighborhood. The eggs benedict is really fabulous, and for lunch, they have this dish called the spring penne paste--comes with fresh mozzarella, olive oil, some cherry tomatoes, and other fresh ingredients. It's really the perfect place to visit before work, they have a warm and friendly environment, a great set of baked goods, and they are efficient for the most part. This place also isn't commercialized as Starbucks has become, and they don't let you just hang out at a table for hours without buying anything. Pros: Friendly service, quick in the morning, delicious breakfast Cons: A bit crowded at times, sometimes difficult to get a waiter more

Excellent Breakfast 6/5/2010

We had breakfast here the other day and the salmon eggs benedict was AMAZING. The salmon was smoked and fresh, it comes with small beet orange salad, and some really unusual and delicious sauce (something Holland sauce, don’t recall the exact name). The salmon eggs benedict is their most popular morning dish and definitely my favorite. The service was relatively quick in the morning, probably because they know people are on their way to work and don’t want to make them wait. Oh, and try their Macchiato, it’s a bit pricey ($4, I think) but SO WORTH IT! Pros: amazing food, good price, very friendly people and nice vibe Cons: They dont have too many places too sit.... more

Excellent Breakfast 6/5/2010

We had breakfast here the other day and the salmon eggs benedict was AMAZING. The salmon was smoked and fresh, it comes with small beet orange salad, and some really unusual and delicious sauce (something Holland sauce, don?t recall the exact name). The salmon eggs benedict is their most popular morning dish and definitely my favorite. The service was relatively quick in the morning, probably because they know people are on their way to work and don?t want to make them wait. Oh, and try their Macchiato, it?s a bit pricey ($4, I think) but SO WORTH IT! Pros: amazing food, good price, very friendly people and nice vibe Cons: They dont have too many places too sit.... more

Good gone bad.... 10/24/2009

This spot used to be my spot. Loved the coffee, loved the pastries! I also used to occasionally dine there. Lately, the prices got jacked up significantly for absolutely no reason!! They became more expensive them Starbucks and even Le Pain Quotidien !!! So I now enjoyLe Pain and occasionally starbucks if I have too! Both are just up or down a block from Georgia. Closer, cheaper, better. So ....save your bucks for better things and get your coffee elsewhere. Georgia's owner, I'm a $2500 customer (on average) a year that you just lost. AND I'M ONLY 1 PERSON! Oh well, deal your (not so smart) business decision. I'm out! Pros: great pastries, ok coffee Cons: EXPENSIVE! more

Good gone bad.... 10/24/2009

This spot used to be my spot. Loved the coffee, loved the pastries! I also used to occasionally dine there. Lately, the prices got jacked up significantly for absolutely no reason!! They became more expensive them Starbucks and even Le Pain Quotidien !!! So I now enjoyLe Pain and occasionally starbucks if I have too! Both are just up or down a block from Georgia. Closer, cheaper, better. So ....save your bucks for better things and get your coffee elsewhere. Georgia's owner, I'm a $2500 customer (on average) a year that you just lost. AND I'M ONLY 1 PERSON! Oh well, deal your (not so smart) business decision. I'm out! Pros: great pastries, ok coffee Cons: EXPENSIVE! more

66 HEALTH CODE VIOLATIONS - LIVE VERMIN ... 5/11/2009

The location is the ONLY good thing about Georgia's!! The SERVICE IS HORRIBLE, food is OVERPRICED - NOT FRESH!!, CLAUSTOPHOBIC seating arrangement!! FILTHY BATHROOM and to top it off it was one of the noisiest dining experiences on the Upper West Side. Save your $$ EAT ELSEWHERE!! Incredibly DISAPPOINTING!! They should forget about trying to be a restaurant and stick with being an over priced bakery/coffee cafe. PS Actually, their baked goods are awful too! As of 4/6/2009 - 66 HEALTH CODE VIOLATION ... Medeocre food and unclean surrounding and TOTALLY OVER PRICED! Check out all the violations .. LIVE RODENTS, LIVE VERMIN EXPIRED FOOD, NO EMPLOYEE HAND WASHING FACILITY, BAD REFRIGERATION .. go look yourself ... Go to the Health & Mental Hygiene site at NYC.gov Read all the hideous violations yourself!! Don't bother!! Pros: Nice location Cons: Bad service, Overpriced, Vermin, Expired Food, Filthy .. more

66 HEALTH CODE VIOLATIONS - LIVE VERMIN ... 5/11/2009

The location is the ONLY good thing about Georgia's!! The SERVICE IS HORRIBLE, food is OVERPRICED - NOT FRESH!!, CLAUSTOPHOBIC seating arrangement!! FILTHY BATHROOM and to top it off it was one of the noisiest dining experiences on the Upper West Side. Save your $$ EAT ELSEWHERE!! Incredibly DISAPPOINTING!! They should forget about trying to be a restaurant and stick with being an over priced bakery/coffee cafe. Pros: Nice location Cons: Bad service, Overpriced, Vermin, Expired Food, Filthy .. more

Nice service, nice coffee, pricey $ pastries; doubtful PR 4/3/2009

Although the flavors were good I had a very specific situation of finding a considerably big and pointy stick in my Canelloni dish which according to the cheff happens to be a Rosemary?? In my mouth it felt like a wooden toothpick. I only received an empty apologize from my waiter. I think a manager's apologize would have been more accurate. Pros: Nice service and flavor but... Cons: Over priced pastry: around $8.00 for a tiny piece of cake!! more

Nice service, nice coffee, pricey $ pastries; doubtful PR 4/3/2009

Although the flavors were good I had a very specific situation of finding a considerably big and pointy stick in my Canelloni dish which according to the cheff happens to be a Rosemary?? In my mouth it felt like a wooden toothpick. Pros: Nice service and flavor but... Cons: Over priced pastry: around $8.00 for a tiny piece of cake!! more
< Previous 1 2 Next >

Menu for Georgia's Bake Shop




CYBERWEEK:
50% OFF all yearly plans
Use CYBERWEEK at checkout. Expires 12/4/2016

Additional information

  • Hours:

    Mon-Fri 7:30am-9:30pm Sat-Sun 8am-9:30pm
  • Payments:

    Cash
  • Neighborhoods:

    Upper West Side, Midtown

Best Deals and Recommendations