If you're in LaHaina looking for some really good food, I recommend Gaby's. Some of us had pizza that was good and I had the Pizza Roll which was Excellent....easy to eat, not messy, and delicious.
The atmosphere was OK, very open to the outside and casual.
The service, however, could have been better. However, I was only there once and this is a pizza joint.
Overall I'd say stop in and have a beer and a pizza roll after an afternoon on the beach!
Pros: Pizza Rolls, Pizza, COOOOOLD Beer!
Cons: Average Service, Not many TV's