JavaScript is not enabled.
Eddie Martini's - Milwaukee, WI - Reviews page 1 - Judysbook

Eddie Martini's

Claim
marker
8612 W Watertown Plank Rd
Milwaukee, WI 53226
marker
(414) 771-6680
Incorrect info? Correct your listing

Photos

Eddie Martini's - Milwaukee, WI
Eddie Martini's - Milwaukee, WI
Eddie Martini's - Milwaukee, WI
Eddie Martini's - Milwaukee, WI
Eddie Martini's - Milwaukee, WI
Eddie Martini's - Milwaukee, WI
Eddie Martini's - Milwaukee, WI
Eddie Martini's - Milwaukee, WI
Eddie Martini's - Milwaukee, WI

Reviews

( 10 )
( 9 )
( 1 )
( 2 )
( 0 )

Best

This is one of those places that you always hear about and have every intention of going to but somehow...

Worst

No matter how well prepared, no steak is worth $30. Everything on your plate is ""extra,"" which is low class on the part of the restaurant. The steak IS good, but I won't go ba...

Old Fashioned Supper Club but not Out of Date Eddie Martinis 8/15/2014

Anita4718 Provided by Partner
Celebrating my birthday and always hearing good reviews, we splurged and had dinner at Eddie Martinis. The atmosphere is an old fashioned supper c... more

Wow! 5/5/2013

It had been years since I last visited Eddie Martini's and I was looking forward to my visit for some time.... more

Editorial review from Citysearch 10/11/2012

Great EAT'S...Nice place for a romantic dinner. The Steaks are perfect and the service was excellent, the only draw back is the price, it's a bit pricey. more

Can't wait to go back 1/8/2012

This is one of those places that you always hear about and have every intention of going to but somehow... more

One of my favorite restaurants! 12/3/2010

If you have a special occasion, this is the place to have it at! I have been here a few times before and wish I could afford to go here more often :) You are missing out if you have never been here before. more

Best in all of Milwaukee 5/6/2010

This is fine dining at its best. Excellent seafood. Amazing wine list. I've been here 4 times in the last year. Don't miss out on this restaurant when in Milwaukee. Pros: Menu more

Perfect steak 11/28/2009

Mr B's is mine and my wife's favorite, and EM's is right there with them. Pros: Food and Service Cons: Parking is small, but you can park on the street too, more

Food:Price ratio 6/23/2008

The food is not as good as the hype (or the price!), but the atmosphere and service are excellent. more

Great Steaks and Chops 5/30/2008

Eddie Martinis is one of the hallmark restaurants in the Milwaukee area. The atmosphere is cozy and the food is great. When the lamb chops are on the menu - be sure to get them as they are excellent. Also a good place to meet after work for a drink. Their martini menu is very good. Pros: Good food quality with creative specials more

Average! 10/26/2006

Ive lived in Milwaukee for over 10 years and usually try every new restaurant close to its opening. However, I only visited Eddie Martini's a couple months ago. The place was hyped quite a bit in my mind. However, I was slightly disappointed with my steak. It wasn't bad, but definitely wasn't as good as some other restaurants in Milwaukee. Their outdoor seating is quite nice on a warm summer evening and the service was excellent! Pros: Parking, Service Cons: None that comes to mind more

Great 3/11/2004

Had dinner and let waitress order for me. Came back with a great meal that was not on the menu, but among the best I have had. People at other tables scrambled to find my dinner on the menu but could not. Pros: Staff, Food, Staff more

Service Excellence 10/24/2003

Eddie Martini's sets the bar of service excellence and exceptional dining experience in the Milwaukee area. Many other restaurant owners should experience it and learn from it! Pros: Best Steaks, Service Excellence, Great Atmosphere Cons: Limited Parking more

Never Better 7/9/2003

If ever in the Milwaukee area, this resturant is a must go. However with such a limited seating area reservations a required. The food is absolutly the best I have had. The steaks are only the tip of Iceberg in there case. The seafood is a must try starting with the Ocean Martini!! A collosal martini glass that is filled with seafood from around the world. Last comment, Great Service! Pros: Food, Service, Wine list more

GRRREAT! 5/15/2003

My wife and I have dined at ""EDDIE'S"" several times and have a hard time chosing any where else. From the Steak to any other item I have never had a bad meal. The service is impecable and the wine list is of very good value. Please try it at your next convience. Pros: Service, Steak, Atmosphere Cons: Drink Prices, Parking, Table by kitchen more

Excellent - bad rank 5/15/2003

Disagree with low rank, should be 2 or 3 on the list. Great supper club feel is supported by wonderful food and service. The martinis rock! Pros: food, martinis, ambience more

Overrated!!!! 2/20/2003

While hearing that Eddie Martini's was one of the best steakhouses in Miliwaukee, I was very dissappointed after eating there. I ordered the ribeye, which was ok, but that was all. I've had better steaks for half the price at other restaurants. It came with garlic mashed potatoes which weren't that great either. If I wanted anything else, I would have had to order it separately. Our bill was also very pricey, considering we didn't even order drinks. The atmosphere was very cozy, and the service was impeccable. There are many great places in Milwaukee to eat out, and enjoy a good steak. I don't feel this is one of them. Pros: Service, Atmosphere Cons: Food, Price more

Eddie has it all 2/4/2003

This cozy restaurant delivers some of the best steaks, wines and service in the area. A comfortable atmosphere greets you at the door, with friendly reception and a lively conversation in the bar. The service once you are seated is second to none, with a team of servers who know the food, and really know their wine. Several times my wife and I were steered in the right direction with their suggestions. Dessert was well worth leaving a little room for and taking some left overs home. My steak was as good the second day as at the restaurant. Pros: food, service, wine Cons: price more

THE BEST OF THE MIDWEST 2/4/2003

Excellent service and food. Waiters are attentive but not annoying.FOod is delicious. Romantic. The number one place to go! Pros: service, parking, ambience Cons: price more

Just around the corner 12/26/2002

This place is overpriced & way overrated. I dont recommend this resturant to anyone. I have not discouraged anyone from trying it, but the comments I have received from my friends have reflected my opinion. more

Wonderful Steaks 12/12/2002

Eddie's has the best filet mignon I've yet to have. I had my steak medium rare and it was MARVELOUS! The wait staff is accomodating and friendly. The environment is relaxing yet a bit formal. I would recommend Eddie's to anyone looking for a great steak. Pros: Great Wait Staff, Relaxing Interior, Classy more
< Previous 1 2 Next >

Menu for Eddie Martini's




CYBERWEEK:
50% OFF all yearly plans
Use CYBERWEEK at checkout. Expires 12/4/2016

Editorial

  • The Scene
    Nestled in the shadows of Milwaukee's medical complex, this 1940s-style supper club has carved a niche with its elegance and high quality. Rich woodwork, bright murals and...

  • 4/2/2004 Provided by Citysearch

Additional information

  • Hours:

    Lunch: Mon-Fri, 11:30am-2pm; Dinner: Mon-Sat, 5pm-10pm
  • Payments:

    Visa, Discover, Master Card, American Express, Diner's Club

Best Deals and Recommendations