Coachman is great for the rates they charge, which are usually lower or within a few bucks of the other good hotels on Whidbey, and the Coachman gives more. We've stayed here more than a few times and found their rooms pretty big, with mini-fridges and granite bathroom countertops, super-helpful front desk clerks, and a really good free breakfast. The owners are local and obviously care lots about their hotel and the guests.
Pros: Super clean. Quiet. Comfortable beds. Local owners!