City Haven is a small realty specializing in downtown Orlando rentals. Most of their properties are in the Colonialtown and College Park areas.
City Haven is a great company to rent from. They offer the benefits of a small-time landlord: quick response and friendly service, with the standardized practices of a larger organization. You're doing business with an established company, not one person and their whims.
Their prices are reasonable, especially in the escalating Orlando real estate market, and many of their properties offer the charm of older properties - rare in a town made up mostly of brand new suburbs.