Circle has been in business for some sixty years. They've proven over time that they know their customers and know what they want. This place has very good selection range for wines in particular, but also champagnes, brandies, and other spirits. There is customer parking behind the store and they are convenient to use. They offer a discount for case purchases and will even deliver for some orders -- let's NOT think frat party.
The price range is very broad and the most important thing is they will give you really good advice. I've particularly enjoyed the "seasoned" recommendations of Circle's knowledgable staff. They've really steered me on to some great values -- not just the most expensive. They take time to listen to your preferences and tailor what they know to what you know -- whether that's a lot or just a little.
We sometimes buy from Paul's over on Wisconsin because it is convenient for us. But when we have the time, this is the place to go.