My boyfriend and I go here on a regular basis, and it consistently great. Judy is one of the best waitresses I've ever had. The bartender makes excellent margaritas. Their daily specials are always great - their fish cakes and salmon cakes are awesome, and their regular menu is great too - the calamari is awesome, and so are the burgers. It's a great place for a casual, delicious, reasonably priced meal. The atmosphere is dark and pub-like, decorated with nautical themed knick knacks. Not super romantic but dark and cozy enough for our taste!
Pros: Excellent food, great service, good specials, good bartender
Cons: Wish it had outdoor seating!