We spent four nights in Galveston for our anniversary. The first night we ate at Fish Tales and it was HORRENDOUS... everything cold, died on the pass, tasteless and bartender was rude and impatient. We went to Casey Gaido's the next night and liked it so much we went back the night after! First night we split seafood-stuffed jalapenos and the grilled seafood platter. All of it was very good. Next night I had the redfish which was to die for and my wife had Robert's shrimp which was also great. We had key lime cheesecake for dessert and it was fantastic. Good drinks, great staff and reasonable happy hour prices too. Highly reccomend Casey's if you want your fix of fresh seafood on the Gulf.