JavaScript is not enabled.
Carmine's Pizzeria - Brooklyn, NY - Reviews page 1 - Judysbook

Carmine's Pizzeria

Claim
marker
358 Graham Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11211
marker
(718) 782-9659
Incorrect info? Correct your listing

Main categories:

Restaurants , Pizza Restaurants

Related categories:

Food & Dining

Reviews

( 10 )
( 10 )
( 0 )
( 0 )
( 3 )

Best

There's two Carmine's locations, I go to the one On Graham Ave., but I hear that the other one is the...

Worst

I ordered a medium and small pizza from their menupages menu. And when I went to pick it up they had a very large and medium size pizzas waiting on me, wanting to charge me over $...

Editorial review from GrubHub 2/17/2014

The lasagna was good,but I had to heat it up because the delivery man got lost. ...the order came at 6:05 instead of between 5:40 & 5:50 more

Editorial review from GrubHub 12/30/2013

very good our family enjoying carmines for 18 years and the owners are so nice more


Editorial review from GrubHub 12/3/2013

Perfect Pizza. Delicious sauce. Crust is slightly chewy in a good way. No shortage of pepperoni. more

Brick Oven 9/2/2013

Love their pizza, I don't know if its because of the brick oven but it comes out so yummy. more

Brick Oven 9/2/2013

Nkirton Provided by Partner
Love their pizza, I don't know if its because of the brick oven but it comes out so yummy. more

Brooklyn Pizza how we like it! 1/13/2011

There are too many types of pizza's to lump them all into one category and judge them all the same. Carmine' s Does What they do Very Well. For a place that serves quick slices and hot plates they do it well, they do it fast and they're priced right.! more

Terrible service, terrible pizza! 10/25/2009

I ordered a medium and small pizza from their menupages menu. And when I went to pick it up they had a very large and medium size pizzas waiting on me, wanting to charge me over $36. I explained that I had only ordered a medium and small, which were cheaper on their online menu. They said that they offered no small size, only large and medium and personal (which the person I ordered with on the phone never mentioned, or corrected me on). They argued in front of me for a while and then eventually took a measly $2 off the bill! Although it was way too much pizza and cost way too much, I would have been happy if the pizza was actually good. It was not. It was extremely greasy and soggy and the meat smelled weird. I would NEVER go back to Carmines, nor would I recommend it to anyone. Here's a tip Carmine...a little bit of customer service goes a long way. Cons: Terrible service, terrible pizza! more

Carmine's 8/9/2008

There's two Carmine's locations, I go to the one On Graham Ave., but I hear that the other one is the... more

Carmine's 8/9/2008

AndyB166ER Provided by Partner
There's two Carmine's locations, I go to the one On Graham Ave., but I hear that the other one is the "original" one. Anytime I have a guest from ... more

great Pizza Betetr Than Anywhere 5/25/2008

Carmines Is Excellent Everyhtign about it the wokrers the foiod everyhtign at a low price and great quality and quanttity I love this place Pros: Great Foood great Pizza Low Price Romatic And Very great for a ny yankee fans Cons: Delivery caould BE a Little Quicker but thats very minor more

Sorry to say this was not one of my memorable... 1/24/2008

Sorry to say this was not one of my memorable pizza experiences in NY. I found the pie to be bland and... more

Sorry to say this was not one of my memorable... 1/24/2008

lorialc Provided by Partner
Sorry to say this was not one of my memorable pizza experiences in NY. I found the pie to be bland and unsavory to my palette. The atmosphere was a... more

Loud, Authentic, Great 10/18/2007

The portions at Carmine's are unbeatable at the price. Once thing that i really enjoyed is that the marinara sauce for the calamari was served at a perfect hot temperature. Speaking of the marinara, my dinner companion and I split the 'small' ($9) and it was tasty and not overly-breaded. We split a caesar salad ($3.25); small of course, but loved that the dresing was served on the side and was a fan of the shaved peccorino romano 'chips' on top. The chicken parmagiana ($7) features two huge chicken breasts over a good-sized portion of pasta. In my two visits to Carmine's, this has become my favorite item. The chicken was freshy and cheesy and again, served piping hot. The personal pizza ($7) was a bit of a letdown; huge, but the 'fresh mozarella' looked suspisciously like white american when singed. The basil and plum tomatoes were tasty, but overall i found the pizza a bit lacking. more

Best service with a smile! 7/22/2007

Excellent stuffed pizza. Offering a delivery service to us during lunch that we utilize often. Always service with a smile! Pros: Located a few blocks from my office! Cons: N/A more

I love IT 5/23/2007

You guys are the best. I try not to eat pizza but I absolutely love yours. I come back again and again. Thank you. more

Best Pizza in Brooklyn 3/26/2007

I just moved to the neighborhood a few months ago and happened upon Carmine's. I'm so glad I did! I've been to quite a few pizza places in Williamsburg and Carmine's far exceeds the rest. Everytime I think of venturing to a new place I'm always disappointed I did not return to Carmine's. I'm here at least once a week now. It's a little cramped for space, but even if you have to wait for a table it's sooo worth it! Pros: Best Pizza! Cons: small space more

Home run but nothing special 3/18/2007

This place had wonderful pizza, absolutely the best in the neighborhood, and some of the best in the entire city. The decor is great - all Yankees memorabilia. The service is unfortunately lacking. Sometimes I feel like I'm invisible, and they do not have a designated 'order here' sign, which would be a great help. Their 'restaurant' in the back served mostly italian-american fare - too-big portions of alfredo, parms, meatballs, too much sauce, etc - comfort food. The service in the back is always atrocious, but I go here because I'm obviously craving something and 99% of the time its right on. Last time I went I ordered the fetuccini alfredo which is usually really good but it came to me as overcooked egg noodles with butter. Totally disgusting. And the waitress couldn't have cared less - she never offered to bring me another plate, she just took it away and didn't even ask about it, which I thought was unacceptable. But again, its usually great and I won't give up on this place - it will be around for a long long time if the quality is there. Pros: best neighborhood pizza place Cons: bad service all around more

great food! 12/30/2006

Carmines is a great neighborhood stample in Williamsburg. Everyone and anyone can be found dining there on any given night. The heros and wraps are all wonderful, the hot dishes are savory and the pizza is amoung the best in the city! High recommendations for the penne with chicken alla karen, pizza steak hero and ceaasar salad pizza ! Although delivery is sometimes slow, its worth it! The service is always great and the restaurant is always accomodating! Best of the best when it comes to great Italian food! Pros: great food Cons: slow delivery more

SOOO good 11/24/2006

I am so fortunate to live near this amazing pizzaria. Always good (have tried several types), and ultra accomodating (they stayed open late once to wait for us to pick up a pie). I know that there are a million pizza places in NYC, but I would rank this up with the best. more
< Previous 1 2 Next >

Menu for Carmine's Pizzeria




HOLIDAY DISCOUNT :
15% OFF all yearly plans
Use YEAR15 at checkout. Expires 12/31/2016

Additional information

  • Hours:

    Monday 09:00 AM - 10:00 PM Tuesday 09:00 AM - 10:00 PM Wednesday 09:00 AM - 10:00 PM Thursday 09:00 AM - 10:00 PM Friday 09:00 AM - 10:00 PM Saturday 09:00 AM - 10:00 PM Sunday 09:00 AM - 10:00 PM
  • Payments:

    Visa, Master Card
  • Neighborhoods:

    Greenpoint

Best Deals and Recommendations