JavaScript is not enabled.
Carmine's Pizzeria - Dallas, TX - Reviews page 1 - Judysbook

Carmine's Pizzeria

Claim
marker
5365 Spring Valley Rd Ste 138
Dallas, TX 75254
marker
(972) 404-8110
Incorrect info? Correct your listing

Reviews

( 13 )
( 2 )
( 0 )
( 0 )
( 1 )

Best

I order it at least once a week........... Great pizza the closet to New York!!!!

Worst

I have ordered pizza from the Campbell location for over 8 years. Tonight I will never order it again. It took over one hour to get here but the problem was it was very COLD. I ca...

Best Pizza in Dallas 2/15/2011

I order it at least once a week........... Great pizza the closet to New York!!!! more

Best Pizza Out Side Chicago 9/6/2010

I have just recently moved to Dallas from Chicago. I consider myself somewhat of an expert when it comes to pizza. I have to say that Carmine's Pizzeria is a m a z i n g!!! Truly! I'm so thrilled! Keep it going! Dallas needs this pizza.. more

Authentic New York pizza 12/19/2009

This was great New York Pizza - thin, crispy, delicious. The thing other posters may not realize is that we have turned our perception of pizza into a delivery item. The best New York thin crust pizza is best when directly out of an oven. When you order delivery, it ruins that crispy crust. Eat the pizza at the restaurant more

Great New York Style Pizza 11/25/2008

Having lived in New York for quite a while, Carmines is the closest thing to make me have the great memories of the pizza I ate while living in NY. I usually resent pizza places that say ""New York Style Pizza,"" etc....but this has completely turned that around. more

do your like cold pizza well this is the place 10/24/2008

I have ordered pizza from the Campbell location for over 8 years. Tonight I will never order it again. It took over one hour to get here but the problem was it was very COLD. I called the restaurant immediately and basically he ignored the problem of the cold pizza. I understand he has delivery problems- but deliver it warm at least. I asked for a refund or a discount or a replacement- he denied all. I was so upset with his lack of customer service I went up to the restaurant.... he was upset with me. He called me a crazy unstable woman. I asked him if he cared about his customers and he said NO. I demanded I leave and would not refund , credit or redo the pizza. He was so rude that the customers at the restaurant said that he should never speak to a woman in the tone he was yelling. This man was almost verbally abusive. When the other customers are telling you to leave because he doesn't care- it's time to leave. I will never order pizza again from the place. I have been a loyal customer for years- but no more. No one should talk to people like this manager did. Talk about poor people skills!!!!!!!!!!! And cold pizza to match his cold personality. more

Best NY Pizza 8/19/2008

Carmines definitely has the best NY pizza ever. I have tried other NY style pizza places in the metroplex but they can't measure up to this place in Addision. I would highly recommend this place! Pros: very good pizza more

Best pizza in Addison 1/1/2008

I love Carmine's pizza. Get the veggie and have them add eggplant (it sounds weird but it is amazing!) We have them deliver all the time. Never go to Dominos or Pizza Hut again--this place is a lot better! It is thin but not as thin as a thin crust at traditional restaurant. It is true new york style pizza-- everyone I know from NY eats here constantly! You can't beat it Pros: Amazing pizza Cons: none! more

Best Pizza in the Metroplex 2/4/2007

Zman187 is wrong, the coit and cambell carmines is not even close to comparing to the spring valley and monfort carmines. Coit and cambell carmines hasnt even got one review on city search, thats how bad there pizza is. Now to the point, Carmines make the best pizza in the metroplex, there dough and suace are made daily to perfection, very fresh pizza with great style. Also there calazone's are fantastic. DeleteReplyForwardSpamMove... \r Previous | Next | Back to Messages Save Message Text | Full Headers Pros: Great Pizza Cons: Parking, Gets to Busy during Lunch more

there is another location 10/5/2006

Coit and Campbell in north Dallas. I think they used to be affiliated, but the Coit and Campbell location is the better of the two. It has expanded, offering more dining room space and a newer, cleaner atmosphere. It is a popular stop for north Dallas police officers and a favorite of all the locals. They have a full menu from appetizers, salads, pizzas, pastas, sandwiches, entrees, and desserts. Don't forget to try a calzone or stromboli. The best pizza place in town!!!!! more

BEST PIZZA IN DALLAS 5/28/2006

I have never had a better piece of pie in my life. The best pizza in town..and i can not believe BJ's is above this place. I would recommend it to anyone. Every one there friendly and they love to talk to the customers. I can't believe how adorable the 21 year old that works there is. He makes the pizza, all girls should check him out:) Pros: Food, Atmosphere, Price more

Very good pizza 3/5/2006

I grew up in NY, and am therefore used to excellent pizza. Carmine's is decent as far as trying to emulate NY style pizza. I've been to several pizza places in Dallas so far (and I do not consider chain pizza places in my search), and Carmine's is at the top for the time being. It's certainly not the best pizza out there, but it's still good! If you want a good, classic pizza, definitely check them out! I was very pleased with quick wait time (they make your pie as soon as you put in your order, and it's done about 15 minutes later). Pros: Inexpensive, Quick service Cons: Location more

Great Pizza 11/8/2005

Checked out Carmine's after reading the review here online. I have to agree, it is some damn good pizza. My wife said it was a little greasy, but that didn't stop her from having 3 slices. It was good, it was great. It tastes great, the cheese tasted great, the toppings looked hand cut, the toppings tastes fresh. This is several levels above Papa Johns and many levels above Pizza Hut -- for the same price. We ordered the pizza for carryout, but the place looks comfy - not brand new, but not run down. The only complaint was that the people who work there were speaking Italian or some other language. The lady at the counter seemed like she was mad about something, but I can't tell for sure since I didn't know what they were saying. Pros: Great tasting pizza, Comfy dining area, Family operated Cons: Family operated, yes -both pro and con more

Great Pizza 11/8/2005

My wife and I when ever we are in the vicinity Carmine's Pizzeria is a must. No fancy decor just a great pie!!! John Wisniewski more

best in town 7/12/2005

family owned and operated for over 15 years, carmines pizza brings you the authentic taste of what ny pizza should taste like. Pros: best pizza, prompt service, taste of italy Cons: none, none, none more

The Best Pizza 7/9/2005

When you go into a pizza shop and order a slice of pizza you expect to get a small cut of pizza, right? But at Carmine's you get a slice that is almost a 1/3 of the whole pizza! I go there almost everyday, but why I can't go every day is because they are clozed on Sunday! Awwwwwwwwww man! Pros: Great Pizza, Inexpensive, Great Overall Cons: Small, Bad Parking more

Ms. 7/6/2003

It's been awhile since I've eaten at Carmine's, but I never forget a good Italian place. I was raised on the East coast in an Italian neighborhood, so when I found Carmine's (during my sojourn in Dallas) I thought I had been transported back ""home"". If you get the chance, eat at Carmine's--that is if you REALLY want authentic Italian food! I know Italian women who would give this 2 thumbs up!!! Pros: Reasonable price, Authentic taste, Great pizza Cons: Sometimes crowded, Was limited parking more
< Previous 1 Next >

Menu for Carmine's Pizzeria




CYBERWEEK:
50% OFF all yearly plans
Use CYBERWEEK at checkout. Expires 12/4/2016

Editorial

  • In Short
    The aromas of Italian spices, ripe tomatoes and bubbling mozzarella fill the air at this popular pizzeria. After ordering at the counter, ample seating is available for large or...

  • 3/2/2005 Provided by Citysearch

Additional information

  • Hours:

    Mon-Thur 11am-10pm Fri-Sat 11am-11pm
  • Payments:

    Diner's Club, Visa, Master Card, American Express, Cash, Discover

Best Deals and Recommendations