It is close to the more famous one, but the food is as good or even better. There just isn't a boat dock and ""floating bar"". The food is better. The banana cream pie is to die for. This is smaller but more cozy. Ask for your cole slaw before the main course. The perch dinner is undoubtedly the best item on the menu. The atmosphere isn't as regal, but it is more honest.
Pros: better parking, less expensive, better quality
Cons: not the "in" place, can be crowded, almost too small